Powered by Blogger.

Home

Showing posts with label Axiata. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Axiata. Show all posts

iCapital Did Explain Why It Lost So Much Money In Axiata!

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Hmmm.... :D

Got a new comment on an old posting: Are My Comments On iCapital Overdone?

  • invest said

    I tend to think your criticism on TTB is rather harsh and overdone considering a few points I which to make :-

    1) TTB did explain the losses in AXIATA in his AGM (those that attended the AGM would know).

    2) ICAP did not buy AXIATA from the market. ICAP got the shares as a result of the spin off of CELCOM (AIXIATA) from TELEKOM.

    3) Due to the rights issues call, ICAP decided not to take up the rights and decided to dispose the entire stake in AXIATA. TTB feels AXIATA might require further cash calls / funding in future for their expansion plan. Hence, ttb decided to sell and channel proceeds to another stock.

    In fact, I found the Q&A with TTB during the AGM was really a wonderful open time where TTB shared some of his thoughts and reasonings.

    I guess those that did not attend the AGM if you are shareholders really missed out.

Let me share some views again.

Firstly, many thanks for highlighting the fact that Mr.Tan did share with his loyal supporters on the massive losses iCapital suffered on Axiata.

Now perhaps let share with you my issue.

On the posting: http://everything27.blogspot.com/2009/06/icapital-lost-14-million-in-axiata.html

The following is the link to the screenshot I had posted on that posting: click here

In that quarterly earnings note, did iCapital explain why it sold? Did it? It did not and for me, it's in my flawed opinion, that it's unjustifiable that iCapital shareholders had to wait for the agm to discover if icapital will explain it losses or not! (In this case, iCapital did explain).

Why is it unjustifiable to wait? Well, iCapital.biz, is a traded entity. And the market, as you know, has it's own mindset. What if the market had sold iCapital down because of the losses? Would this be an impossible scenario? So why can't iCapital explain it losses in its earnings notes?

Is this such an impossible request?

To not explain in their earnings notes and to explain it only in the agm is like icapital telling their investors, 'hey we got huge losses in Axiata (14 million), you do not have to be worried for the next xxx of months. Just wait for my agm, then I will explain'. (In this case, icapital shareholder had to wait more than 2 months to find out the reasoning.)

Does that sound ridiculous?

For some, it does not but for some it's not only ridiculous but ludicrous! Reason? Lack of transparency and lack of respect to the investing public.

Now that was my point.

Did I blast iCapital for not explaining the Axiata loss in its AGM? No, I did not! My point from day one was that iCapital did not bother to explain its MASSIVE losses in its AGM. its quarterly earnings notes!

Regarding points 2 and 3. Thanks for highlighting this issue. Now if one wasn't a shareholder, would they have known? They would not yes?

And let's look at the reason why it sold its shares in Axiata.

Quote: "Due to the rights issues call, ICAP decided not to take up the rights and decided to dispose the entire stake in AXIATA. TTB feels AXIATA might require further cash calls / funding in future for their expansion plan. Hence, ttb decided to sell and channel proceeds to another stock. "

Now this is such a SIMPLE and ACCEPTABLE explanation, yes?

And if I had own Axiata, I might even consider selling based on the exact same reasoning. It was a simple and logical explanation. It's really a no brainer.

So why can't iCapital explain this simple reasoning to the investing public right after it sold it's shares in Axiata? Why did iCapital wait until the AGM (a couple of months later) only to explain what had happened?

Again, I ask, is such an action acceptable?

For me, I find it unacceptable.

Last but not least, if you think that I pointing out this issue as being overdone and harsh, well that's your right of opinion but I will not apologise for pointing out something that I clearly find as unacceptable.

Strange don't you think so?

Everything only wants to talk about the positive.

Those that point out the negatives are deemed as bad folks.

Hey, guess what? I do not have any problems with that. Serious! You see that's your right to only focus on the positives and ignore the negatives. Perhaps in this world, the negatives do not exist.



Read more...

Featured Report: OSK Research On Axiata

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

The following article on the Edge Financial Daily, OSK upgrades Axiata to buy caught my attention.

  • OSK Research yesterday upgraded its recommendation for Axiata Group Bhd to buy from trading buy with a higher price target of RM3.40 on expectations of better earnings from its two main subsidiaries Celcom (M) Bhd and PT Excelcomindo Pratama (XL).

    “We expect XL to report a headline net profit in 2Q09 on the recovery in mobile spending and a gain in the rupiah of some 12% year-to-date.

    “Our recommendation on the stock is upgraded to a buy from trading buy on growing conviction on the earnings delivery of its overseas mobile assets and our view of diminishing medium-term concerns over its balance sheet,” OSK Research said in a note....

I was aroused. LOL! I was excited yo!

I wondered. Would OSK be consistent in their recommendation?

Or perhaps would I be seeing their incredible flip-flop on price targets as seen in recent postings like Featured Report: OSK Research On Astro All Asia or Featured Report: OSK on Pelikan Holdings or What Hope For Malaysian Investing Public When Research House Makes Such Calls?

Let's track back on OSK recommendation on Axiata since the start of the year....

I think I will add in the last report made in 2008. At least we know how their recommendation ended last year. :D

And just for the record, on 28th April 2008, OSK initial coverage on Axiata (or TM International - old name) had Axiata as a buy with a TP of 9.20.


OSK ended 2008 with a Neutral call on Axiata. Price target was 4.20.

8th January 2009.


Feb 6th 2009. Axiata falls to 3.18. OSK held firm despite market chatter on possible writedown on Idea for Axiata. :D (consistent so far yo! )


19th Feb 2009. YIKES!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Recommendation is stated as NEUTRAL and target price remained at 4.20 but they threw in a screw or curve ball!!!

If you look at the second arrow above this NAUGHTY LINE stood out like sore thumb! Quote "Our forecast and target price are under review pending the release of its results on Feb 26. TMI remains a long-term BUY."

Macam mana ni?

The recommendation is NEUTRAL and the last I knew, neutral is neutral is neutral. A neutral does not equate a long term buy!

Perhaps I am from another planet!!

And then I was also confused. (as usual. :p2 )

On 6th Feb 2009, Axiata was 3.18 and the so-called Neutral price was 4.20. Well that's an upside reward of 1.02 or 32% based on a reference price of 3.18. 32% precent woh! How come the recommendation was NEUTRAL? ( macam mana ni? )

You know that at the end of every OSK report, they have this explanation of their recommendation calls and this is the snap shot of it....

So as per their report: "Neutral: Share price may fall within the range of +/- 10% over the next 12 months"

hmmm....... :p2

Feb 26th 2209. Axiata announced its quarterly earnings. Its losses was more than 515 million!

And with the rights issue, OSK correctly reduced the target price.

However as usual I was baffled. Why? I was baffled with their insistent on having Axiata at NEUTRAL! (Yeah, OSK is the only one in town who can cut target price by some 28% and yet can still maintain their recommendation. oO )

  • RECOMMENDATION

    Maintain NEUTRAL
    . Target price cut to RM3.00. We slash our FY09/10 forecasts by 14-28%, mainly to reflect weaker EBITDA margins on average of 37% versus 38.5% previously due to the higher operating cost environment for most of its overseas assets. Our revised projections see TMI posting a slight earnings contraction of 4% for FY09 before recovering to 19% in FY10, driven in the main by lower interest charges following the de-leveraging of its balance sheet.

    We believe the market may have already priced in the risk to certain extent of a dilutive recapitalization exercise, with TMI’s share price hitting a record low of RM3.02 earlier this month. That the pricing of the rights shares has yet been fixed could potentially result in further dilution should its share price weaken further. As such, we now attached a 20% discount to our SOP target of RM3.76 to derive our new target price of RM3.00.

    We would turn buyers of the stock should the share price dip below RM2.70.

March 24th, Axiata fixed the rights issue at 1.12. It was a rights to buy five new shares for every four shares held. (hope my england is a ok. :p2 )

March 25th. Price is now 2.61. Their call? Take profit. TP downgraded to 2.50!



I kid you NOT!

What kind of recommendation is take profit????? ( Macam mana ni? Axiata had been plunging since listing... got what profit to take????? )


Wait it's now only March 2009. Less than one year ago, OSK had Axiata at a buy with a TP of 9.20!

Lucky I got that report to share.


March 2009... Global markets were bouncing and our market too was 'panas'.

And guess what was OSK next recommendation?

Upgrade to NEUTRAL with TP remaining at 2.50! LOL! I kid you not! Have a look yo!


LOL!

One month later.... came another shocker!!!!!!!!!!!!

28th April 2009. OSK downgrades Axiata once again! LOL!

Axiata then traded around 2.10 and OSK gave it a TP of 1.73. oO


And once again.... what's the meaning of TAKE PROFIT? (apa ni?)

Where's my chart of Axiata?


The above chart shows the performance of AXATA from listing till 30th April 2009. It would be pretty hard to take profit, yes? ( unless of course one is a super duper trader. Oh.. do remember to ask iCap on this one during the upcoming AGM. :D )

And oh yeah, do check this past posting on 25th March 2009:
What A Trading Day For TMI. Axiata or TMI had a brutal day that fine March day.

May 20th, OSK then upgrade Axiata to a trading buy to 2.70!
  • ... upgrade our recommendation to a TRADING BUY from TAKE PROFIT as our previous concerns over the overhang arising from the listing of its rights shares appear to be unjustified. Our sum-of-the-parts target price is now raised to RM2.70 (from RM1.73), factoring in the independent contribution from Idea and after rolling over our valuation on Celcom to FY10.




June 18th. Trading buy maintained at 2.70.


July 8th 2009. Trading Buy maintained at 2.70.



And as most are aware, Axiata had been rather hot lately. Yesterday, OSK made another update on Aziata. And guess what? They raised their TP for Axiata to 3.40.


So how now my dearest?

Axiata TP is now 3.40 woh!

You want or not, cheh?

:p2


Recommendation history and price target.

  1. 24th Dec 2008. Axiata 3.58. Maintain Neutral at 4.20.
  2. 08th Jan 2009. Axiata 3.60. Maintain Neutral at 4.20.
  3. 06th Feb 2009. Axiata 3.18. Maintain Neutral at 4.20.
  4. 19th Feb 2009. Axiata 3.36. Maintain Neutral at 4.20.
  5. 28th Feb 2009. Axiata 3.06. Maintain Neutral. TP lowered to 3.00.
  6. 25th Mar 2009. Axiata 2.61. Take profit. Downgrade. TP lowered to 2.50.
  7. 30th Mar 2009. Axiata 2.38. Upgrade to Neutral. TP at 2.50.
  8. 28th Apr 2009. Axiata 2.10. Take profit. Downgrade. TP lowered to 1.73.
  9. 20th May 2009. Axiata 2.32. Upgrade to trading buy! TP at 2.70.
  10. 18th Jun 2009. Axiata 2.28. Trading buy maintained. TP at 2.70.
  11. 08th Jul 2009. Axiata 2.42. Trading buy maintained. TP at 2.70.
  12. 21st Jul 2009. Axiata 2.98. BUY upgrade. TP at 3.40.

Read more...

Axiata And Its EBITDA Targets.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

In another Business Times article: Axiata: Financial targets achievable

  • Mobile operator Axiata Group Bhd is confident of meeting its main financial targets this year although first quarter results were slightly "off target".

    Its first quarter revenue increased 5 per cent over the same period last year. Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (ebitda) fell 7 per cent.

    Axiata had targeted revenue to increase 6-11 per cent and ebitda, 4-6 per cent.

    "The first quarter is traditionally weaker. The growth is not linear ... Growth in many countries should be getting better," Axiata group chief executive officer Datuk Seri Jamaludin Ibrahim told reporters after its annual general meeting in Kuala Lumpur yesterday.

    Axiata operates in Indonesia, Sri Lanka, India, Singapore, Bangladesh and Cambodia.

    To achieve its ebitda target, it will continue to manage costs better. Initiatives include tower-sharing, better procurement and redesigning its network, among other things.

    It already plans to cut spending by RM1.2 billion, 20 per cent of which will be due to better efficiency.

    Compared with last year's fourth quarter results, Axiata's first quarter revenue and ebitda were 19 per cent and 36 per cent higher respectively, while net profit more than doubled.

    On another development, its 83.8 per cent-owned Indonesian unit, PT Excelcomindo Pratama (XL), may raise between US$300 million and US$600 million (RM1.07 billion and RM2.13 billion) via a rights issue for its recapitalisation plan.

    "What we are looking at is to see if there is a better and more optimal capital structure that can make XL more efficient capital-wise, perhaps reduce their interest, restructure the loans, and others.

    "There's no problem with XL. The business is good, the cash flow strong, the bank lines are there, and nothing can stop them from growing even if we (Axiata) do not do anything," Jamaludin said.

    XL, which has seen a 4 per cent dip in customer base in the first quarter, is embarking on a different market strategy. Instead of spending more resources to attract new customers, it is seeking to generate more revenue from existing customers.

I have only one issue.

  • To achieve its ebitda target, it will continue to manage costs better.

EBITDA is earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization.

And for the minority shareholder, what good is the EBITDA? Not a whole lot because the ITDA is real.

The Interest cost from the capital funding incurred by the company is real. Some call it the cost of capital. So is the taxes.

And all capital equipment will become obsolete one day. This is why depreciation costs is real.

So when a company focus on achieving EBITDA targets, I find it rather amusing. It's rather meaningless. I would rather the company show its shareholders the NET PROFIT!!

Hence, for me, I rather see Axiata focus on its net earnings target. This is more meaningful.

And yet again, just my flawed views.

Read more...

CIMB's Comments On Axiata

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

CIMB's comments on Axiata.




Above expectations? Waaazzap doc?

I have no idea what the following line means...

  • 1Q09 core net profit is significantly above our and market expectations even though on annualised basis, it missed our forecast by 3% and consensus by 9%.

I just cannot under standing that how can the earnings can be significantly above their expectations and yet it's below their annualised forecast?

And oh, how nice that CIMB forecast is on CORE net profit.

Looks like another new financial yardstick for me.

How now my dearest Brown Cow? Looks like my brains must be too flawed to understand.

Read more...

Quick Look At Axiata's Quarterly Earnings

On the Edge Financial Daily: Axiata up in active trade after upgrade

  • CIMB Equities Research upgraded Axiata from Neutral to Outperform in view of the telco's recapitalisation which lifted a key concern, its share price plunge and its positive view of Celcom and Idea.

    “We expect strong 1QFY09 results from Celcom, driven by corporate demand, mobile broadband and a strong take-up from the youth segment for its prepaid product. Idea is poised for very strong growth, aided by its expansion into the remaining seven circles.

    “We are cutting our FY09-10 forecasts by 6-26% for earnings downgrades for XL and delay in contributions from Idea due to hold-ups in the merger with Spice. Our SOP-based target price for Axiata is unchanged RM2.65,” it said.
In its report, CIMB wrote the following on Axiata's earnings review.
  • 1QFY09 results preview
    Axiata is scheduled to announce its results on 19 May, followed immediately by a conference call.

    Turnaround expected. After the plunge to a core net loss of RM21m in 4Q08 from a net profit of RM362m in 3Q08, we expect Axiata to post a core net profit of RM160m- 200m, primarily on the back of a sharp turnaround in XL’s contribution to RM4m profit from a core net loss of RM149m in 4Q08. We expect smaller losses from TMIB qoq but we caution that earnings visibility there is extremely poor.

And if you do have a copy of CIMB's earnings notes, CIMB states that they prefer SingTel.

  • RM2.65 target price. We retain our rights-adjusted SOP-based target price of RM2.65 in which Celcom features as the heavyweight. The potential re-rating catalysts are strong growth from Celcom and Idea as well as a turnaround for Excelcomindo. Axiata is our top Malaysian telco pick given its higher-growth and more attractive valuations. However, among the regional telcos, we prefer SingTel for its higher exposure to emerging markets and better quality assets.
I guess what CIMB actually prefer is not important. What important is to state that the stock is up. :p2

Anyway, Axiata just announced its earnings.

This is what it reported.


ps. the earnings per share is rather muddled. Not my fault lah. Axiata in its quarterly earnings notes states that it is using the weighted average number of shares of 3,753,402,000 shares. As it is, from my live quotes, I see that Axiata has some 8,455,154,455 shares. ( And as you know, weighted average number of shares is rather silly since one cannot buy based on weighted average shares. )

Axiata today closed up at 2.32, up 11 sen or 4.977%. :D

How? Priced up or priced in? :p2

Read more...

What A Trading Day For TMI

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Blogged this morning: Hello Bro, This Is TMI Calling

In loving memory, this is TMI's performance for today.






Some newsclip:

  • TMI skids in early trade, down 28 sen
    Written by Joe Chin
    Wednesday, 25 March 2009 09:30

    KUALA LUMPUR: TM International’s share price fell sharply in early trade on March 25 when it resumed trade after a one-day suspension to announce its rights share price.

    At 9.22am, the KL Composite Index fell 2.32 points to 875.6. Turnover was 40.24 million shares valued at RM63.79 million.

    TMI was down 28 sen to RM2.33. There were 7.96 million shares done.

    Other decliners were Tenaga and Public Bank, down 10 sen each to RM6.10 and RM7.40.

    On March 24, TMI had fixed the issue price of its rights offer at RM1.12, with an entitlement ratio of 5-for-4.

    OSK Investment Research said the EPS dilution was significantly higher at 49%-52% of FY09/10 EPS (vs the indicative 34% dilution earlier).

    However, they said this was not unexpected given the delay in fixing the price and the fact that TMI’s shares have fallen 29% since the proposal was announced on Feb 26.

    “We downgrade our recommendation to Take Profit from Trading Buy following the 20% rally over the past three trading days. We expect the market to react negatively to the larger-than-expected dilution.

    “On an ex-rights basis, its FY09/10 PERs are not particularly attractive at 10.2-12.7 times given the challenging outlook for its overseas businesses,” it said.

  • Path cleared for TMI to begin anew
    Written by Cindy Yeap
    Wednesday, 25 March 2009 10:11

    KUALA LUMPUR: TM International Bhd (TMI) shareholders approved all eight resolutions, including a RM5.25 billion rights issue and name change to Axiata Group, at a meeting that lasted over four hours yesterday, but it was not smooth sailing all the way.

    Approval for the renounceable five-for-four rights issue, fixed at RM1.12 apiece just ahead of the EGM yesterday, came by a show of hands after lengthy deliberations. But its proposed performance-based employees share option scheme (Esos) involving the issuance of up to 7% of its share capital met resistance from minorities.

    TMI chairman Tan Sri Azman Mokhtar was prompted to ask for vote via a poll, where one’s vote is based on respective shareholding, to see the three resolutions on the Esos through.

    The poll was called after he could not determine a conclusive outcome despite calling for a show of hands three times. This was again met with some protest by minorities, but the company’s legal adviser said the request for poll was allowed, citing Article 76 of TMI’s articles of association.

    To be fair, the Minority Shareholders Watchdog Group (MSWG) CEO Rita Benoy Bushon described the proposed Esos structure as “exemplary”, given that several performance thresholds for the company and the employees had to be met to determine eligibility. She called for greater transparency in its implementation.

    TMI Group CEO Datuk Seri Jamaludin Ibrahim told shareholders that it would be in a position to consider paying dividends to shareholders when the group’s cash flow “starts” turning positive “towards end-2010”.

    TMI Group chief financial officer Datuk Yusof Annuar Yaacob expects the whole TMI Group to be cash flow positive in 2011.

    But that was not enough to satisfy some minority shareholders, who wanted TMI to first show results and deliver shareholder returns, before considering the Esos.

    They voiced dissatisfaction about how TMI’s share price had tumbled from RM7.85 last April to the RM2 levels currently, wiping out RM20 billion in market capitalisation.

    Of those present, shareholders holding 7.7% of the company’s equity voted against the proposed Esos, while over 92% voted for it.

    Khazanah Nasional Bhd owns 44.51% of TMI. Employees Provident Fund board (EPF) has 15.76%, while Permodalan Nasional Bhd’s Amanah Raya Nominees Sdn Bhd holds 8.52%.

    Meanwhile, TMI said in a statement it had entered into underwriting agreements with CIMB Investment Bank, RHB Investment Bank and Maybank Investment Bank for the 55.49% or 2.6 billion of the rights shares, excluding Khazanah’s entitlement.

    Khazanah has undertaken to fully take up its portion and commit to subscribe to another 20% of the rights issue.

    EPF owns 57.55% of RHB Capital Bhd while PNB controls 52% of Maybank. Some RM85 million is estimated as the cost of the rights exercise, including the underwriting.

    TMI shareholders also approved that Khazanah be exempted from making a mandatory general offer (MGO) if one were to be triggered from the rights issue.

    The rights issue, expected to be completed around the first week of May, will see each TMI shareholder forking out an average of RM1.40 (RM1.12 per share multiplied by five rights shares then divided by 4 TMI shares) for every TMI share he owns.

    Any renounced rights entitlements are expected to be traded mid-April (T+13 days), Yusof said.

    The RM1.12 issue price represents a 50.9% discount to the five-day volume weighted average market price (VWAP up to March 23) of RM2.28 and 31.7% discount to the theoretical ex-rights price of RM1.64 (based on RM2.28 VWAP). TMI shares, suspended yesterday, closed at RM2.61 on Monday.

    Based on TMI’s last closing price of RM2.61, TMI’s theoretical ex-price is RM1.78.

    Kenanga Research maintained a buy call “on an ex-basis”. “Short-term weakness could be expected given the recent 20% uptick from the low as well as the larger-than-expected share issue”, Kenanga Research said in a note yesterday. TMI added 45 sen in three days prior to its suspension.

    “For traders, we would be looking at the rights-to-the-rights for opportunities. Based on the theoretical ex-rights price of RM1.78 versus the rights of RM1.12, the rights-to-the-rights shares should be priced around 66 sen maximum,” Kenanga said.

    TMI expects to see at least some RM240 million per annum in interest savings from the repayment of RM5.15 billion debts from the rights proceeds. Half or RM10.5 billion of TMI Group’s RM20 billion debts is at the holding level.

    RHB Research estimates TMI’s FY09-FY11 net debt/Ebitda (earnings before interest, taxation, depreciation and amortisation) will fall to between 2.2 times and 2.6 times from 3.1 times and 3.6 times pre-rights issue.

    Based on a theoretical ex-rights price of RM1.78, RHB estimated TMI’s FY09 and FY10 price-to-earnings ratio (PER) would rise to 11.2 times and 10.6 times, respectively, versus 8.4 times FY09 earnings per share (EPS) and 7.9 times FY10 EPS currently, as its share base balloons from 3.75 billion to 8.4 billion shares.

    RHB yesterday lowered its fair value for TMI to RM2.72 from RM3.45 after imputing a higher discount to reflect the dilution from the rights exercise, and retained its “market perform” call.

    Yusof also told shareholders that TMI intended to pay Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM) “quickly over the next couple of weeks”, earlier than the April 25 deadline because there was an immediate interest savings, given that the RM4 billion due to TM carried a 6.5% interest rate per annum, higher than TMI’s average borrowing cost of 4.67% per annum.

    Yusof said it would invest between RM15 million and RM25 million in brand promotion for its new name Axiata. This is RM5 million to RM10 million more than the RM10 million to RM15 million it would have cost the company to continue spending to build the existing TMI brand.

    A new name that bore no resemblance to TM was chosen to eliminate any “confusion” in the branding between the demerged companies. Jamaludin said the new logo for TMI would be unveiled in “mid-April”.


    This article appeared in The Edge Financial Daily, March 25, 2009.

  • OSK Research: Take profit on TMI
    Written by Joe Chin
    Wednesday, 25 March 2009 10:51

    KUALA LUMPUR: OSK Investment has downgraded TM International to Take Profit from Trading Buy after the company fixed the issue price of its rights offer at RM1.12 with an entitlement ratio of five for five.

    It said in a research note on March 25 the earnings per share (EPS) dilution was significantly higher at 49%-52% of FY09/10 EPS (versus the indicative 34% dilution earlier), which is not unexpected given the delay in fixing the price.

    The research house also said TMI’s share price had fallen 29% since the proposal was announced on Feb 26.

    “We downgrade our recommendation to Take Profit from Trading Buy following the 20% rally over the past three trading days. We expect the market to react negatively to the larger-than-expected dilution.

    “On an ex-rights basis, its FY09/10 PERs are not particularly attractive at 10.2-12.7 times given the challenging outlook for its overseas businesses,” it added.

    OSK Investment said based on the proposed five-for-four rights issue, the level of dilution would be significantly higher at 49%-52% for FY09/10 EPS (interest savings net of tax) versus the circa 35% it would have recorded had the rights price been fixed much earlier.

    TMI’s share price fell by up to 30% from the level when the rights issue was proposed on Feb 26. With the 4.69 billion rights shares to be issued, the issued share capital will balloon some 125% to 8.44bn.

    OSK Research said the net gearing would ease to 0.6 times from 1.3 times currently, with the RM5.15bn proceeds used to pare debts. “Our target price is maintained at RM2.50 (RM1.73 ex-rights basis),” it said.

    The research house also said there could be a potential impairment from its acquisition of a 15% stake in IDEA in 3Q 2008.

    “We had previously excluded IDEA in our SOP valuation on TMI. We believe that should the impairment charges be accounted for, TMI may have to write off some RM3.8 billion for its 15% stake given that IDEA’s share price has fallen by some 70% since the acquisition was announced at end-2Q08,” it said.



Read more...

Hello Bro, This Is TMI Calling

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Posted the other day, Hello TMI, What's Up Bro?

Let me highlight that one section again.

So in the second set of news we have TMI saying..

  • Dominant fixed-line phone company Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM),(4863) which posted a 73 per cent fall in 2008 net profit, said it will return RM3.51 billion cash to shareholders after sister company TM International Bhd (TMI) agreed to repay a debt it owes in the next quarter. .........
  • "There's no reason for us to keep the excess cash ... By returning cash in excess of its requirement to shareholders (98 sen a share), TM is providing immediate value enhancement,"

What do we have here? First it wants to do a US$1 billion rights issue (this is about rm3.6 billion or so) because bank borrowings too much. It also wants to pay back TM rm3.51 billion because it has excess cash.

How now brown cow?

On today's papers: TMI to sell shares at 57pc discount

  • TMI to sell shares at 57pc discount

    Published: 2009/03/24

    TM International Bhd, Malaysia’s state-controlled mobile-phone operator, offered to sell stock at a 57 per cent discount in a rights issue to raise RM5.25 billion (US$1.4 billion) and help pay off debt.


    Shareholders will be able to buy five new TM International shares for every four owned, the company said in a filing to the stock exchange in Kuala Lumpur today. TM International is offering RM4.69 billion new shares at RM1.12 each, less than half the stock’s closing price of RM2.61 yesterday on the Malaysian stock exchange.

    TMI, which has assets in Asian countries, including Indonesia and India, is seeking to raise funds to repay RM4 billion of debt to former parent Telekom Malaysia Bhd next month,
    and refinance about US$2 billion of loans used to invest in a mobile-phone operator in India.

    “Times are not good, business is quite tough, so to entice the shareholders, it has to be a big discount,” said Lye Thim Loong, who helps manage about US$500 million including TMI shares at Avenue Invest Bhd in Kuala Lumpur.

    Kuala Lumpur-based TMI said on March 11 it planned to offer the rights shares at as much as 40 per cent discount to their ex- rights price, or the price it estimates the stock will trade at after the offer.

    Bigger Discount

    The discount is “bigger than expected,” said Izz Al-Din Maslan, an analyst at AmSecurities Holdings Bhd in Kuala Lumpur who rates TMI stock “sell.” While the issue could lead to a 45 per cent dilution to the company’s earnings per share in 2009, investors should take up the offer to avoid bigger losses following the drop in the stock price, he said.

    TMI follows Malayan Banking Bhd in selling shares to raise funds as the global economic slowdown and the tightening of the credit market have made it increasingly difficult for companies to obtain loans.

    Malayan Banking, the country’s biggest lender, is raising RM6 billion selling new shares to existing investors at a 43 per cent discount to shore up its capital after making acquisitions last year.

    TMI had tumbled as much as 30 per cent since February 26, when the company announced the rights issue plan. The stock recouped some of the losses in the past three days after analysts said the declines were excessive.

    The shares were suspended from trading today for the sale announcement. The company is holding a meeting with shareholders to approve the rights offer. The stock added 11 per cent to RM2.61 yesterday.

    Malaysia’s state investment agency Khazanah Nasional Bhd, which owns 45 per cent of the company, has said it is prepared to subscribe to as much as 65 per cent of the rights offer. The country’s Employees Provident Fund, which controls about 20 per cent stake, has also said it will take up its portion in the rights offer, TMI has said. - Bloomberg

How?

TMI does the rights issue because this is what's owed to its parent TM.

How nice of TMI to settle this godzilla sized debt in the midst of a global financial crisis.

And after receiving this money, TM, as promised, would give a bumper dividend to its shareholders.

How bro?

Hard to fault this issue because this was promised earlier and a known fact but if you are a TMI shareholder and you are not aware of this arrangement, it does feel a little awkward because the money that you subscribe these rights issue will be the money used by TM to pay the dividends.

How bro?

Here is a report from KN.



And this is what RHB folks has to say.

Read more...

Hello TMI, What's Up Bro?

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

The following set of news caught my attention.

'TMI aiming for US$1b rights issue'


  • SINGAPORE/KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysian mobile phone company TM International (TMI) (6888) is looking to raise more than US$1 billion (US$1 = RM3.67) in a rights offering in the first half of this year to cut debt, sources with direct knowledge of the deal said yesterday.

    Analysts said TMI is facing significant pressure to lower its RM10.45 billion debt, while its overseas businesses are also being hit by the economic slowdown.

    "TMI will do a rights and the issue size is over US$1 billion,"
    one of the sources said, declining to be identified because the deal is not public.

    JPMorgan and Goldman Sachs, which are advising TMI on the fundraising, declined to comment.
    A TMI spokeswoman said nothing has been finalised yet, but the firm is on track to announce details of its capital raising plan in the first quarter.

    In a report yesterday, Citigroup said TMI may need to raise capital because of an expected US$300 million cash shortfall next year and about US$600 million to US$700 million capital spending.

    "A rights issue or a debt issue - both of which will prove challenging in our view," said Karen Ang, a Citi analyst.

    Malaysia's state investment arm Khazanah Nasional Bhd, which owns 44.51 per cent of TMI, said last month the mobile company will issue right shares or some other equity-linked instrument this quarter to raise funds to repay some of its debt. - Reuters
LOL!

I like how they said "sources with direct knowledge of the deal" and "one of the sources said, declining to be identified because the deal is not public."

Now this is called narrowing down the sources! Inside info eh? Ho ho ho!

Anyway let's not talk about sources this morning.

So TMI wants to do a rights issue worth maybe over US$1billion to lessen the size of its debts.

Now this sounds like the right thing to do but in US dollars now?

And then I saw the other news
TM to return RM3.51b to shareholders, pay dividends


  • Dominant fixed-line phone company Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM),(4863) which posted a 73 per cent fall in 2008 net profit, said it will return RM3.51 billion cash to shareholders after sister company TM International Bhd (TMI) agreed to repay a debt it owes in the next quarter.

    TM, which will receive the full amount of RM4.03 billion by April 24, said the capital repayment exercise, pending shareholders' approval, would be completed by end of second quarter.

    "There's no reason for us to keep the excess cash ... By returning cash in excess of its requirement to shareholders (98 sen a share), TM is providing immediate value enhancement," said group chief executive officer Datuk Zamzamzairani Mohd Isa in Kuala Lumpur yesterday.

    Besides the capital repayment of RM3.5 billion, the company also agreed to pay a final dividend of RM382 million.

    The company said its capital repayment exercise will not change its dividend policy of returning at least RM700 million to shareholders.

    The move, which is expected to be positively received by investors, has also raised some concerns.

    An analyst who declined to be named said the company should set aside more cash (from TMI's repayment) for working capital and repay bank loans.
    "It's like giving all your salary to your parents when you have bills still to pay," said the analyst.

    TM, which has started rolling out the RM11.4 billion national high-speed broadband (HSBB) project, said it has no funding worries currently and enough cash internally to fund the project.

    The company is expected to spend RM1.7 billion on the HSBB project this year, of which half (RM850 million) will be subsidised by the government. Besides the RM1.7 billion commitment, the company will spend RM1.5 billion or less on non-HSBB related capital expenditure.

    Nevertheless, group chief financial officer Datuk Bazlan Osman said TM has ample room to gear up without hurting its credit ratings.

    "There is a potential of debt head room moving forward. If you look at our balance sheet, we do have quite a fair, if not good, debt-to-capital or debt-to-EBITDA ratio.

    "We believe we should be able to maintain our current rating, which is 'A-' by the foreign rating house, and 'AAA' by the local rating house," said Bazlan.

    Analysts expect TM shares to rise today, mainly driven by the capital repayment announcement.

    "It will generate interest in the stock market ... 98 sen a share capital repayment for a stock trading at around RM3.30, that's a handsome return of nearly 30 per cent already," said an analyst.

    The company's fourth quarter net profit grew 5.7 per cent to RM166 million, while revenue grew by 18.7 per cent to RM2.5 billion, helped by growth in the broadband and data businesses.

    However, for the full year ended December 31 2008, net profit fell by 73.2 per cent to RM229.3 million, mainly due to exceptional items like foreign exchange losses.

    Broadband revenue jumped by more than 25 per cent to RM1.48 billion, while broadband customer base expanded by 26.7 per cent to 1.6 million users in 2008.

    Fixed-line voice revenue declined 9.6 per cent to RM4.4 billion, due to fixed to mobile migration.

So in the second set of news we have TMI saying..

  • Dominant fixed-line phone company Telekom Malaysia Bhd (TM),(4863) which posted a 73 per cent fall in 2008 net profit, said it will return RM3.51 billion cash to shareholders after sister company TM International Bhd (TMI) agreed to repay a debt it owes in the next quarter. .........
  • "There's no reason for us to keep the excess cash ... By returning cash in excess of its requirement to shareholders (98 sen a share), TM is providing immediate value enhancement,"

What do we have here? First it wants to do a US$1 billion rights issue (this is about rm3.6 billion or so) because bank borrowings too much. It also wants to pay back TM rm3.51 billion because it has excess cash.

How now brown cow?

I am so baffled.

And I so fully agree with the analyst that declined to be named!

  • An analyst who declined to be named said the company should set aside more cash (from TMI's repayment) for working capital and repay bank loans. "It's like giving all your salary to your parents when you have bills still to pay," said the analyst.

Read more...

  © Blogger templates Newspaper by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP