Powered by Blogger.

Home

Showing posts with label Financial Shenanigans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Financial Shenanigans. Show all posts

SC Gets Injunction Against Ishak

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

The drama continues...

  • SC gets injunction against Ishak
    Written by Surin Murugiah
    Wednesday, 16 June 2010 16:54

    KUALA LUMPUR: The
    Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) has obtained an ex-parte injunction to refrain Datuk Ishak Ismail from dealing with RM10.2 million, proceeds from his disposal of about 58.7 million shares of Kenmark Industrial Co (M) Bhd.

    In a statement Wednesday, June 16, the SC said the Kuala Lumpur High Court also ordered Ishak to furnish full and complete details of his assets, whether in Malaysia or elsewhere, within four days.

    The SC said it sought the injunction following its investigations into suspected breaches of securities laws by Ishak.

    Investigations in the meantime are actively being pursued on possible breaches of securities laws within Kenmark, especially with respect to its previous board, management and key shareholders, it said.


Recent postings on Kenmark

  1. So What has Ishak Done With His Block Of Kenmarks Shares Purchased
  2. Did Kenmark Case Proved That Buy And Hold Investing Strategy Does Not Work?
  3. Can Kenmark Survive?
  4. Kenmark Finally Discloses In Detail Why It Suffered 146 Million In Losses But...
  5. Theory On Kenmark's Soaring Trade Receivables And Massive Provision Of Bad Debts
  6. A Deeper Look At Kenmark Losses
  7. Kenmark Suffers 146 Million In Losses!
  8. Kenmark: It's Now Kidnap Case!
  9. More Incredible News Flow From Kenmark!
  10. Kenmark: Sorry But I Was Sick
  11. More On Kenmark
  12. Kenmark: MD and Deputy GM 'resigns', Share Plummets Big Time!!!

Read more...

SC Warns On Destroyed Documents

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

On Business Times

  • SC warns firms not to destroy documents

    Published: 2010/06/16

    THE Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) yesterday issued a stern reminder to directors and principal officers of public-listed companies (PLCs) of the severe consequences of destroying or causing loss of company documents.

    Under the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007, it is an offence to destroy, conceal, mutilate or alter any record or account with the intent to defraud any person, or to prevent, delay or obstruct investigations, the SC said yesterday.

    Upon conviction, offenders are liable to a fine of up to RM10 million or imprisonment for up to 10 years or both, it said in a statement.

    According to SC chairman Tan Sri Zarinah Anwar, it is completely unacceptable that a company that is under investigation suddenly turns around and claims that documents are lost or stolen.

    "I am reminding directors of PLCs that they are ultimately responsible for the safe custody of company documents and can be held liable for the loss of such documents," Zarinah said.
    "Someone who assists another person to destroy documents also commits a wrong. So I am sending a strong warning to company employees and others who act on the instructions of those further up the corporate chain," she said.

    Zarinah warned that the SC would not not hesitate to take action against anyone responsible for the destruction, loss or removal of any company records.

    The SC said it was extremely concerned that in some of the cases under investigation, documents central to the investigations had been reported lost, destroyed or even stolen.

    "While recognising that there could be genuine cases of loss, there appears to be losses which seem to have occurred under extremely questionable circumstances," it said.

    The commission called for heightened vigilance on the part of company directors, auditors and key company officials with regard to the safeguarding of all company documents.

    The SC also reminded auditors that they have a duty to report any breaches of securities laws or rules of the stock exchange or any matters which may adversely affect the financial situation of a PLC to the authorities.

    "This is a critical role of auditors who are expected to bring a level of independence and professionalism to the process of financial disclosures," it said. - Bernama


I believe that article should be addressed to Axis Inc.

Axis Inc Lodges Police Report!

All I want to repeat say is that in 2007, Axis Inc the stock had a bumper year.

Stock soared on the basis that the company's business had reported fantastic growth. With the fantastic growth came incredible surge in trade receivables.

So the stock soared in 2007.

In 2008..

  • Axis Inc Bhd may have to write off RM161 million in its 2008 accounts as its auditor could not find enough evidence to show that the company could recover the amount. ..... One is an amount of RM105 million due from contract manufacturers, which is part of other receivables as at March 31 2008. ( see Update on Axis Inc )

Yup... all hell broke loose in 2008.





Now Axis said.. cannot find.. missing... so it lodged a police report.

Think about it... record sales drove the stock up in 2007... in 2008.. records cannot verify those sales and receivables..... 2010.. those records now missing!

Yup.. completely unacceptable!

Read more...

So What has Ishak Done With His Block Of Kenmarks Shares Purchased

Monday, June 14, 2010

Ok, there's no rule that one cannot buy and sell shares but do think about the following announcement just posted on Bursa website..


  • The Board of Directors of Kenmark was today received verbal confirmation from Dato' Ishak bin Ismail that he has ceased to be substantial shareholder of Kenmark on 9 June 2010. He has indirect interest via Unioncity Enterprises Ltd, a substantial shareholder of the Company, which has today notified the Company vide the Form 29C dated 10 June 2010 that they have disposed of 27,691,900 Kenmark shares in the open market on 9 June 2010.

    A representative of BHLB Trustee Berhad for a discretionary trust for the family of Dato' Ishak bin Ismail ("the Trust") has today verbally confirmed to the Company that the Trust has on 10 June 2010 acquired 1,000,000 Kenmark shares and on 11 June 2010 disposed of a total of 31,000,000 Kenmark shares.

Here's the data that matters.


4 June 2010, I wrote
More Incredible News Flow From Kenmark!

And last but not least... in the Star article
Ishak is Kenmark’s biggest stakeholder

  • “James (the MD) called me on Monday night to help him out as he is sick. This is the company we both floated in 1997 when I was the bumiputra shareholder. However, I sold my shares a long time ago,’’ he told StarBiz

Monday night?

In the posting Kenmark: Sorry But I Was Sick

  • "James Hwang in his letter has stated that he has been unwell and unconscious and was also uncontactable. He has now regained full consciousness but still physically weak," said the company in a statement to Bursa Malaysia on Wednesday, June 2.
  • "It was only yesterday (Tuesday) I regained full consciousness but am still weak to travel," he said. He did not identify the nature of the sickness nor did he say when he expects to be well.Hwang will only return to Malaysia once he is healthy.Hwang also said he could not be reached by telephone as all calls had been barred by family members.

Sorry I am confused.

Ishak got the call on Monday night. If James Hwang was in China, say Beijing, the time zone would be the same as here, yes? So can I assume Monday night as in Monday night Malaysia time?

And James Hwang states he only regained consciousness on Tuesday.

Hmmm..... how?

And Ishak bought 20 million shares on Monday. See Link here

How now Brown Cow?

-------------------------------------

YES HOW DID ISHAK BOUGHT THE SHARES ON MONDAY??

NOW he said he sold on the 9th??????

Such a significant announcement and Kenmark only announced today??????

WOW!!!!!

Bought on 1st and 2nd ... sold on the 9th!

Go figure!!! Go do the math!!!!!!!!!

Guess how much profit was made by this friendster who lend his helping hand!!!

Yeah... Robin Hood or what?????

BAH!

Read more...

Axis Inc Lodges Police Report!

Friday, June 11, 2010

Oh no!!!!

Just when I thought I could have a nice weekend enjoying the World Cup, I noticed this news clip on the Edge Financial Daily: Axis Inc directors lodge police report over missing records

  • KUALA LUMPUR: AXIS INCORPORATION BHD 's board of directors has lodged a police report over several official documents and records belonging to Axis and its units which have gone missing.

    It said on Friday, June 11 that it had on Wednesday
    lodged the report over the missing records of the company and its units Asiapin Sdn Bhd, Chongee Enterprises Sdn Bhd and GBC Marketing Pte Ltd from 2004 to 2008 at the offices in Johor Baru, Tangkak and in Singapore.

    The missing records
    included documents in relation to the purchase of machinery sent to contract manufacturers in Cambodia and/or Vietnam; bank statements and cheque butts; payment vouchers and supporting documents for payments made to the contract manufacturers in Cambodia.

    Also missing were documents, letters, e-mails and correspondences between Axis group and the contract manufacturers; documents in relation to the orders placed with the contract manufacturers by buyers; documents of raw materials bought for the contract manufacturers (ncluding purchase orders and delivery orders).


    The report also claimed that documents on the account of monies received from the Bumiputera issue in 2004 and the sale of Ganad assets in 2007-2008 were missing.

    "As a result of the above missing records, Axis Group of companies in 2009 had to write off substantial amount of its assets and receivables due to the lack of documentary support of these assets and receivables," it said.

    The company said the present Axis Board was unable to answer certain queries posed by Bursa Malaysia Securities Bhd.

Dear lord!!!

Let me get this correct.

Axis Inc is blaming that because of these missing documents, Axis Inc had to write off substantial amount of these assets and receivables!

  • .. lodged the report over the missing records of the company and its units Asiapin Sdn Bhd, Chongee Enterprises Sdn Bhd and GBC Marketing Pte Ltd from 2004 to 2008 at the offices in Johor Baru, Tangkak and in Singapore.

Gee how nice!

Now I had written on Axis before. Aug 2008, I wrote A Deeper Look At Axis Inc.

Let me reproduce one of the compiled tables here again.


Clearly visible and questionable was the 2006 fiscal year earnings, in which its earnings slumped big time from 14 mil to 8 million but the massive sudden increase in loans from 85 million to 184 million stood out sorely. Receivables jumped insanely from 82 million to 166 million!

The next fiscal year 2007, Axis had a bumper year! Axis Inc the stock had a bumper year too!






Bumper year means good stock, yes? Apparently, the market liked what it saw when Axis net earnings jumped from 8 million to 25 million!

But sadly, the market discounted the incredible balance sheet weakness! (see the above compiled table again). Loans soared to an incredible 240 million and trade receivables stood out sorely at 200 million!

Today, Axis is saying "As a result of the above missing records, Axis Group of companies in 2009 had to write off substantial amount of its assets and receivables due to the lack of documentary support of these assets and receivables,"

Consider the fact that record profits helped drove up the stock in 2007.
Consider the fact that the record profits came with the insane jump in receivables!

Now all the records and documents are all missing! Would anyone be able to examine the debt aging reports? Will anyone understand why the receivables jumped? And without these records, how could anyone determine the validity of the profits made in 2007, since the documents are all missing?!!

WOW!

Like this also can!

What a wonderful world we live in!

Are we all Ah Bengs and Ah Lians???

First we have the Kenmark CEO saga. Now apparently Axis wants its throne back!

----------------

ps:

I wrote on Axis back on 31st July 2008: Regarding The Plunge Of Axis!!

This was followed by A Deeper Look At Axis Inc and then by More On Axis Inc and Update on Axis Inc.

In the posting More On Axis Inc

  • The external auditor, Messrs Horwath are unable to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence and explanations to ascertain the following:- (b) the recoverability of the outstanding balances due from the Contract Manufacturers (net of the settlement subsequent to 31 March 2008) in relation to the trade receivables and advances)

Axis since then saw the company being hit by huge provision of bad debts and then served with writ of summons by its banker, Maybank and later saw its auditors, BDO Consulting Sdn Bhd, alleging that 'some serious discrepancies with regard to transactions that had led to earlier write-offs from the company’s books'.

Do see this brilliant article on Star Businessweek: Once rescuer Axis now needs rescue

Read more...

Can Kenmark Survive?

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Kenmark shares were slaughtered yesterday. It plunged some 46%! It went from 27 sen to a mere 14 sen!



And surprisingly
Bursa CEO calls Kenmark MD’s behaviour irresponsible

Now the biggest questions for me are the following...

  1. Would we see more losses from the company?
  2. Can the company survive?
  3. Would we see more disposal of shares by the major shareholders?
  4. What about Ishak - the so-called friendster?

These are massive questions, yes?

Yes, I know it's getting tedious and perhaps boring but besides these issues, there's something not right.

Yes! Something happened and it's not right!!!

Posted yesterday: Kenmark Finally Discloses In Detail Why It Suffered 146 Million In Losses But...

In that posting, I included data from a worksheet which Kenmark submitted in its announcement to Bursa.

This morning I clicked on my 'source' of data, Debtor Aging.xls and I found it to be an invalid address. Then I realised Kenmark has removed that worksheet and replaced it with another new one.

They said the following...

  • Further to the Company’s announcement on 8 June 2010 in respect of the reply to Bursa Securities on the quarterly results for the financial period ended 31 March 2010, the Board wishes to inform that the “Debtors Aging” attachment file was inadvertently forwarded with the announcement. The attachment file is errorneous as it only contains the debtors aging for affected companies where provisions for doubtful debt were made. Attached is the corrected file indicating the summary of the total debtors and the aging analysis of the Kenmark Group.

Well let me say this. I do not think it was erroneous. Instead, I am glad I saw and took the snapshot of the file. And most importantly, that 'debtors aging' showed one important data, which is the debt that was written off came from 3 main debtors, which are BILLION CREATOR (HK) LTD, DAILY EMPIRE TRADING LIMITED and EVER VICTORY (HK) LTD.

Why did Kenmark want to remove the file?

Did these 3 companies who saw their debts being written off by Kenmark stood out sorely????? ( refer Kenmark Finally Discloses In Detail Why It Suffered 146 Million In Losses But...)

Take Billion Creator. It owed Billion Dynamic Sdn Bhd 44.565 million. Billion Dynamic wrote the whole sum off. Billion Creator owed Kenmark Industrial 7.1 million. Kenmark Industrial wrote off 4.23 million off to just 2.875 million and Billion Creator still owes Kenmark (Labuan) close to 3 million.

I cannot help thinking. If I am Billion Creator, and I see Kenmark writing off close to 49 million off from what I owe them, what should I do about the remaining 5.8 million owed to Kenmark group of companies?

How?

My say?

The fact that bulk of the write down came from 3 companies and given what has transpired, Kenmark should NOT have removed the file. This is a rather important disclosure of information to the investing public!

Anyway.. back to the main issue.

1. Would we see more losses from the company?

The general impairment of fixed assets was scary. Given the limited data, there's no way I can ass-u-me that there will be NO MORE impairment of fixed assets.

Remember, Kenmark only did a 10% general impairment of fixed asset left idle due to the current interruption of its business.

And the more I thought about it, the more I am baffled.

Kenmark's reported earnings submitted was for the period ending 31/03/2010 and the current mess only happened on the last week of May 2010.

First thing that came to my mind, how could Kenmark provided for such general impairment of fixed asset since the current interruption of business only happened end May 2010? It was like Kenmark was providing for losses for events that had not happened.

Then I came to my senses. :P

Sales revenue... sales revenue... check out the sales revenue.

On Feb 2010's reporting quarter, Kenmark said it had 101 million in sales. Ok that sales figure is so questionable now, given what is happening, because the previous reporting quarter in Nov 2009, Kenmark sales revenue was only some 35 million. So on a q-q-q basis, sales went from 35 million to 101 million to just 18 million (current quarter, Kenmark sales was only some 18 million).

Leaving out issue of 'fudged' numbers, from 101 million to 18 million, is indeed a serious interruption of business.

Which meant that Kenmark's troubles was known months ago!

That would be my assumption. Yes I ass-u-me and if I am wrong, I am making an ass out of you and me.

Now if that's the case, then most likely than not, it is possible to see more general impairment of fixed asset left idle! That would be guess! And I again I stress, I am guessing and I could be wrong.

How much impairment would we see? Well current quarter of general impairment of 10% already equated some 29 million! So go figure. My guess is that the figures would be huge the next quarter!

Provision of bad debts.

Let's have a look at the resubmitted Debtor Aging summary1.xls (yeah, it's a summary!)

Now the file is too wide, so I again hid some columns and showed debtor aging from 150 days onwards.

And I added myself a total of the debts over 150 days and more. See the arrow highlights in the table below.


Why am I doing this? (click on the table above for a larger view)

Come next quarter, these figures would be 180 days and above already and by any industry standard, such debts are pretty much doubtful.

And what do we have? After the provision of bad debts, Kenmark's receivables over 150 days is more than 51 million.

How much of these would be bad?

Did another calculation. The receivables over 210 days is about 9.878 million. This would the figure I would ass-u-me could be written off come the next quarter! Yes, meaning to say, it's possible to see provision of bad debts of at least 9.8 million come the next quarter!

That's my flawed guess. Ok?

Next... Can the company survive?

Let's see the bare facts.

Cash on hand as reported for the period ending 31/3/2010 was stated as 440 thousand!

Total loans outstanding is 139.043 million!!!!!

And trade payables is a massive 83.958 million!!!!

Can Kenmark even pay its bills???

Perhaps sale of assets is imminent!

But how much are the assets really worth?????

Kenmark's impairment of its machinery from its current quarter is a whopping 15 million!!!!!

What's the exact book value of these machinery?

How?

I do not even know how to ass-u-me its assets value.

3. Would we see more disposal of shares by the major shareholders?

Last night Kenmark siad its Taiwanese shareholder, Chen Wen-Ling also reduced its stake. LOL! The other day, was James Hwang.

Which makes it all so disgusting.

Really.

Think about it.

Given the state of the horrible mess Kenmark is in, the major shareholders and the boss, had been disposing their shares like plague!

Would they continue to dispose their shares?

Think about it.

Lastly, What about Ishak - the so-called friendster?

Hey, he was the friendster who lend the helping hand hor. And he bought his stake on 1st and 2nd June. That was when Kenmark was below 10 sen.

So how? Is this friendster really a 'Robin Hood' or is the friendster in for pure profits only?

Go think about it....

Read more...

Kenmark Finally Discloses In Detail Why It Suffered 146 Million In Losses But...

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

So what do we have? Kenmark submitted its quarterly earnings, which was clearly an insult to the investing public in the manner they presented the report in which they showed utter no respect to the investing public by NOT disclosing how much was provided in their provision for doubtful debts! Thank goodness the folks at Market Surveillance, Securities Commission realised that this is not right as it was not only misleading AND there was no effort from Kenmark to show how it had suffered so much losses. Hence the stock was suspended yesterday. Now Kenmark did made a reply and because it did the stock will resume trading today.

However, for those who took a look at what was reported must have been shocked at what was submitted to Bursa.





Comments:

1. Fixed asset - general impairment = 29.383 million.
2. Fixed asset – full impairment as idle asset = 22.439 million.

WOW!

So we have fixed asset general and full impairment causing losses of over 51 million!

Now I am not an accountant or auditor but if I have vested interested in Kenmark, I would definitely would want to see WHY such a huge provision is needed on its fixed asset.

Then we have provision of doubtful debts.

General provision at 100% (exceed 12mths) = 69.206 million!!!

Size of the provision is mind boggling!

Now if you look at point #2

Fixed asset – full impairment as idle asset = 22.439 million.

This is explained by the following..

Yes, from the above, we can see that provision for 'idle assets' consisting of machinery totals a whopping 15 million!

Key word, idle.

And of course, the inquiry mind wants to know the original book value of the machinery and needless to say why the machinery are left idle!

Common business sense, why did Kenmark buy such valuable machinery but only to be left idle!

Regarding point #1.

1. Fixed asset - general impairment = 29.383 million



Assets not fully utilised due to current interruption of business amounts to a whopping 29.3 million.

What's interesting is its assets in Vietnam. The impairment losses totals some 23.2 million and this is only a 10% impairment. Yeah.. go figure the size of its plants in Vietnam. And given the size of the plant, how come Kenmark business the previous years, never show any potential at all? Don't you wonder? I certainly do.

Source:
Appendix A.doc

Next we have the doubtful debts issue - the 69.2 million issue!

Now the provision of bad debts comes from 3 companies.

  1. Kenmark Industrial Co. (M) Bhd
  2. Billion Dynamic Sdn Bhd
  3. Kenmark (Labuan) Limited

Kenmark Industrial.

Firstly the screen shot belows shows that it is such a joke how Kenmark conduct its business! Its business aging has columns for over 330 days!!!

Now because the aging has so many columns, I will show only from 180 days onwards..

(the above table is clicakable for a larger view)

Comments.

The above table shows the before and after bad debts provision.

From the formula embedded, Kenmark's amount is only considered due after 180 days. In layman's term, this mean, you can buy a product from Kenmark, the product is only due for payment after 180 days! ( ps. if one is interested in looking at Kenmark from a business investing perspective, one could dig out recent quarterly earnings and look at Kenmark's recent OPERATING PROFIT MARGINS and evaluate if there was any justification for Kenmark to run business in such a manner, ie allow its customers to pay only after 180 days. Why? If the margin is small (ie 10% or less) then common sense would dictate that it's simply suicidal to conduct business in such a manner!)

From the worksheet, it appears that some 25.182 million was written off as bad debts from Kenmark Industrial Co. (M) Sdn Bhd. (you can get this figure by subtracting 20.379 million from 45.562 million.)

Note the 3 'big' companies benefiting from the provision of bad debts: BILLION CREATOR (HK) LTD and DAILY EMPIRE TRADING LIMITED and EVER VICTORY (HK) LTD.

Now if I suspect something is amiss or if I suspect any hanky panky, I would dig up more info in these 3 companies. Yeah, check if there is 'freindly' relationship between these 2 companies and Kenmark.

Oh yeah, the amount due which is over 330 days totals 24.641 million!!!

Next we have Billion Dynamic Sdn Bhd.

Hmmm... Billion Dynamic Sdn Bhd and Billion Creator (HK) Ltd ..... hmmmm.... first name... same!

!!!

Very straight forward!! (the above table is clickable for a larger view)

Billion Creator (HK) Ltd owes Billion Dynamic Sdn Bhd 44.565 million. This amount is over 330 days.

Wiped clean!!

!!!!

No more debts owing from Billion Creator to Billion Dynamic!!!

Simply. Easy peasy!

Lastly, we have Kenmark (Labuan) Limited.

(the above table is clickable for a larger view)

Not much provision was made but note the 3 companies again. BILLION CREATOR (HK) LTD and DAILY EMPIRE TRADING LIMITED and EVER VICTORY (HK) LTD.

The bulk of Kenmark's debts comes from these 3 companies.

And it seems that Billion Creator (HK) is the luckiest company in this saga. Owed Kenmark and subsidiaries so mcuh money, now most wiped clean. No need to pay!

Good or what?

Source: Debtor Aging.xls

So how?

Do you like what you see?

One big question for me...

ok, one can just slam Kenmark for being a bad business for allowing its customers (or 3 companies - Billion Creator, Daily Empire Trading and Ever Victory) to run up such massive debts on a relatively insane credit terms of over 180 days but what I want to know is why now?

Yes, why now.

Take their quarterly announcement reported last year. (I will paste what I had posted previously)

May 2009: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/3/2009
2008 Q4
Sales 38.775 million Net LOSS 0.084 million Receivables 163.773 Million Cash 2.222 million Total borrowings 144.574 million.

Yes, receivables last year was already an insane 163.773 million.

Now what I want to know is, from this 163.773 million, how many of the debts were over 180 days? Were there any debts over 330 days back then?

Sorry but surely the inquisitive mind would want to know, yes?

And how long ago has Brilliant Creator being a customer of Kenmark?

These are the simple questions that needs to be answered.

And yes, the ownership in these 3 companies. Are they 'friendly' to Kenmark boss? How close is the friendship?

Last but not least...

We all know Kenmark boss was said to be sick or unconsicous or maybe kidnapped. (Sorry, I simply do not know what to believe, hor)....

From Bursa website: http://announcements.bursamalaysia.com/EDMS/edmsweb.nsf/LsvAllByID/20BC43B4778D69064825773C003C329F?OpenDocument

  • Further to our announcement dated 3 June 2010, the Directors wish to inform that based on the Record of Depositors dated 7 June 2010, the shareholding of Mr Hwang Ding Kuo @ James Hwang is 14,193,792 Kenmark shares or approximately 7.96%.Mr James Hwang on 23 April 2010 notified that he has 53,363,092 Kenmark shares (29.93%).This announcement is dated 8 June 2010.

Yeah, finally when queried, Kenmark finally disclosed the above information!

I wonder if no query, when would Kenmark disclose?

From owning 29.93% on 23 April 2010, James Hwang shareholding suddenly shrank to a mere 7.9%

Go figure!

Yes, the boss has been dumping his shares like mad!!!!

What's MOST UTTERLY DISGUSTIBATING is....

1. No disclosure on when his shares were sold.

2. No disclosure on the price transacted.

Surely this is not acceptable!!!!!!

( see also: Theory On Kenmark's Soaring Trade Receivables And Massive Provision Of Bad Debts )

Read more...

Theory On Kenmark's Soaring Trade Receivables And Massive Provision Of Bad Debts

Monday, June 7, 2010

Got an extremely good reply from Richard Cranium on the posting A Deeper Look At Kenmark Losses



  • How about this for a theory?

    1. They "moved" all the stocks to a friendly or a shell company, accounting for a significant rise in receivables.

    2. The sales figures subsequently dropped as there is no more inventory due to (1).

    It would be interesting to see where the stock went to i.e. which distributors/retailers has the largest intake. Won't surprise me if these are in China or place far away from Malaysian law.

    Just a hunch,



That's a pretty interesting theory or hunch. :D

Let me reuse the same frame as what I had posted earlier and put the focus on Sales, Inventory and TRADE PAYABLES.



I put in trade payables because sometimes sales do not come directly from a company's inventory. Meaning to say, sometimes a company could buy a product from another source and then re-sell that product.

The recent earnings again...

Feb 2010:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/12/2009
2009 Q3
Sales 101.441 million Net Profit 4.769 million Inventory 22.847 million Trade Payables 106.347 million.

Nov 2009:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 30/9/2009
2009 Q2
Sales 35.334 million Net Profit 3.718 million Inventory 28.241 million Trade Payabales 103.577 million.

Aug 2009:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 30/6/2009
2009 Q1
Sales 57.686 million Net Profit 1.013 million Inventory 38.687 million. Trade Payables 63.958 million!

(Moolah: OMIGOOOOOOSH! Jackpot!




Compare the inventory in this quarter versus what was reported on Nov 2009! See how inventory declined from 38.687 million to 28.241 million the next quarter. See how Trade payables soared from 63.958 million to 103.557 million!

How could the payables jumped so high? Sales this quarter was only 57.686 million and the next quarter sales plunged to 35.334 million???!!!! And payables increased by 39.599 million!

Questionable issue or what??? )

May 2009: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/3/2009
2008 Q4
Sales 38.775 million Net LOSS 0.084 million Inventory 30.853 million Trade payables 34.310 million!


(Moolah: WOW!

Trade payables in Q4 was only 34.310 million. The next quarter it was 63.958 million. And the next quarter it was 103.557 million. And the next quarter 106.347 million!!!!!!!!!!!!

Holy cow!!!)


And the following was from last night:

Last night, June 2010:
2009 Q4
Sales 18.762 million Net LOSS: 146.552 million Inventory 20.104 million Trade payables 83.958 million!!!!


WOW!

Exactly!

When one views the inventory and trade payables together, it paints one new ugly picture altogether!!!!

How now brown cow?????

Tell me if this is not sheer financial shenanigans!

Read more...

A Deeper Look At Kenmark Losses

Last night I wrote Kenmark Suffers 146 Million In Losses!. It was rather lacking, so I decided to make a better posting on it.

Firstly let me dig up some recent earnings...

Feb 2010:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/12/2009
2009 Q3
Sales 101.441 million Net Profit 4.769 million Receivables 248.662 Million Cash 2.210 million Total borrowings 142.203 million.

(Moolah: Comparisons are made versus the previous quarter. Sales. Sales for the quarter was incredible. Over 101.441 million. Last quarter 35.334 million only. What happened? Why the sudden surge?)

Nov 2009:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 30/9/2009
2009 Q2
Sales 35.334 million Net Profit 3.718 million Receivables 225.317 Million Cash 2.298 million Total borrowings 143.354 million.

Aug 2009:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 30/6/2009
2009 Q1
Sales 57.686 million Net Profit 1.013 million Receivables 207.584 Million Cash 2.202 million Total borrowings 144.463 million.


(Moolah: Comparisons are made versus the previous quarter.Look at how the receivables 'suddenly jumped' to 207.584 million. Last quarter, receivables were 'only' 163.773 million. And the fact the next quarter the receivables jumped again to 225.317 million! What on earth is happening??? Compare the receivables to the sales revenue! Unreal isn't it? 2009 Q1 Kenmark had sales revenue of 57.686 million, yet it carried receivables of 207.584 million!!!! Insanity! How on earth can any company run a business in such a fashion? A cash balance of only 2.2 million and total debts of 144.463 million? Was there any way possible such a business could survive???? And from an investor perspective (and mentioned before in the posting, More Incredible News Flow From Kenmark! , quote: "Perhaps it was grossly over priced at 90 sen given the state of its business fundamentals, in which its poor balance sheet was clearly visible!")

May 2009:
Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/3/2009
2008 Q4
Sales 38.775 million Net LOSS 0.084 million Receivables 163.773 Million Cash 2.222 million Total borrowings 144.574 million.


And the following was from last night:

Last night, June 2010:
2009 Q4
Sales 18.762 million Net LOSS: 146.552 million Receivables 152.339 Million Cash 0.440 million Total borrowings 139.043 million.


Sales suddenly plummet to only 18.762 million!!!!
Cash is clearly gone.
Massive provision of doubtful debts is made resulting the company losing 146.552 million.
So massive that the company declined to state EXACTLY how much bad debts was written off!
And the debts of 139 million looks incredibly massive when the company has almost no money!

ps: when receivables keep ballooning like in Kenmark's case, these receivables sooner rather than later will need to be revised as bad debts!

And we have the incredible news of the boss - 'runaway', 'sick', 'unconscious'.....and best of all, a helping hand from an old friend who decided to purchases tons and tons of shares BEFORE he got the call for help! (I wonder if the call was made in a conscious or unconscious state?) ( see More Incredible News Flow From Kenmark!)

And to cap it all... they claim it's now a kidnap case!


Seriously... who does the company think we are?

Ah Beng or Ah Lian?

Oh yeah.. the helping friend... he was so fortunate to buy container loads of the stock on the 1st and 2nd June.

Do compare the prices then and today (27 sen).

And if Kenmark share goes any much higher, this helping friend, sure is well paid for helping out eh?

And of course the jealous guys or the sour cows (LOL!) would accuse... 'plunge the stocks on bad news, grab as much as possible when the shares are almost worthless and the push it up, up and away!'

LOL! They are only jealous!

But seriously.... do you blame them for being jealous?!


( see Theory On Kenmark's Soaring Trade Receivables And Massive Provision Of Bad Debts also)

Read more...

Kenmark: It's Now Kidnap Case!

Friday, June 4, 2010

My name is not Willy Billy either!

You cannot be serious!

Seriously.

  • The drama continues: it now appears that managing director James Hwang Ding Kuo is a kidnap victim.

    The drama continues to unfold in Kenmark Industrial Co (M) Bhd (7030). It now appears that managing director James Hwang Ding Kuo is a kidnap victim.

    The group's new executive chairman Datuk Abd Gani Yusof, executive director Ho Soo Woon, and independent non-executive director Woon Wai En said this was reported by Kenmark's office in Taiwan but they could not clarify when and how the said incident took place.

    "That is what we were told by officials at Kenmark's office there," Abd Gani told reporters in a media briefing in Petaling Jaya, Selangor, yesterday.

    Hwang, Kenmark's managing director and major shareholder, went missing and was uncontactable as the group's fortune took a rapid turn for the worse since May 26. However, he resurfaced last Thursday, claiming to have fallen ill in China on May 24 and been in a delirious state.
    Hwang did not identify the nature of the sickness nor did he say when he expects to be well and travel back to Malaysia.

    Kenmark's new directors had their first board meeting on Thursday to determine the actual situation of the company and identify the next course of action.

    "We have met with key management staff and they have agreed to come back to work immediately," he said, noting that the factory expects to be operational next week. Kenmark's factory in Port Klang has production turnover worth RM30 million a month.

    "Our priority now is to get the business started and production running ... in the same time, get out from PN17," he said.

    The board will meet again on Monday and hope that they would have a firm plan by then.

    On Thursday, former KFC Holdings (Malaysia) Bhd deputy executive chairman Datuk Ishak Ismail emerged as Kenmark's biggest shareholder with a 32.36 per cent stake.

    As to whether Hwang will remain as managing director of Kenmark, Abd Gani said Hwang will be advised to step down.

    Kenmark shares, which resumed trading yesterday after a two-day suspension, more than doubled to 26 sen from 11.5 sen before.

    Kenmark also clarified that there was no default on the credit facilities, totalling RM20.9 million, granted by EON Bank Bhd.

    "There were some trade bills due for payment at end of May but due to Hwang's absence, it could not be paid and EON Bank in safeguarding their interest had then appointed the receivers on Kenmark Paper Sdn Bhd."

    As to its Vietnam business, the directors were told by Hwang Vietnamese authorities asked to take control of the premises because there were looting during the absence of senior management staff.

    Kenmark has also asked Bursa Malaysia for more time, or until June 30, to submit its financial results for the period to March 31 2010. However, Bursa Malaysia could not consider it because the request was not made in time, or 15 days before May 31.

    Read more: Kenmark: MD was kidnapped
    here

While all this going on... the stock plunged from 90 sen to 3.5 sen and then miraculously rocketed to a high of 29 sen!

My say?

Just suspend this stock!

Read more...

More Incredible News Flow From Kenmark!

Thursday, June 3, 2010

In the posting: Kenmark: Sorry But I Was Sick


  • 1. First bankers demanded some 72 million back from Kenmark.

    2. Then Kenmark said the MD resigned.

    3. Kenmark MD said he's sick. Was unconscious. Only woke up yesterday. (Apparently he claim he is still the MD)

    4. MD does NOT state what sickness that caused him to be unconscious.

    5. But... you cannot call him. Apparently family members barred all calls.

    6. Two executive directors from Taiwan has gone missing. MD did not state where they were.

    7. Apparently... a friendly party has bought a huge stake in the company. (hmm.. no changes of shareholders announcement made on Bursa. hmmm...... stock rallied yesterday (many did not know why))

    8. Company has NOT released its earnings.

    9. Company is now a PN17 stock and is currently suspended (yeah.. after surging like crazy yesterday!)

    10. Pricewaterhouse is contacted to determine the actual debts of the company.

    11. MD will only return back to Malaysia when he is healthy. Apparently he's too sick to travel.

Things have now gotten even 'better'.

Regarding Point 7. Apparently the deputy executive chairman is the buyer of the stake. (sorry. typo. Ishak is not the deputy chairman of Kenmark)

  • Datuk Ishak Ismail, former KFC deputy executive chairman bought 32.36 per cent of Kenmark, a furniture maker, on June 1 and 2

    DATUK Ishak Ismail, KFC Holdings (Malaysia) Bhd's former deputy executive chairman, is now a major shareholder of financially-troubled Kenmark Industrial Co (M) Bhd (7030) as he bought while others were busy dumping the stock.

    He bought 32.36 per cent of Kenmark, a furniture maker, on June 1 and 2, as the stock hit record lows of between 3.5 sen and 4.5 sen.
    The group did not say who were the sellers.

    Kenmark also did not say how much he paid for the stake but based on the closing and last traded prices of the two days, Ishak could have spent about RM6 million.
    He may have even paid much less, or probably half of that, if he had bought the stake at the days' lows.

    Kenmark, a PN17 company, has yet to report its fourth quarter numbers for the period to March 31 2010 as its managing director and major shareholder James Hwang, a Taiwanese, went missing since last week.
    From then on, the group went into a tailspin as two banks said it defaulted on loans, named a receiver to a subsidiary while all operations ground to a halt and some 400 of its workers were uncertain of their future.

    Kenmark is now the subject of Securities Commission (SC) probe while Bursa Malaysia has ordered it to appoint a special auditor to ascertain if there are any irregularities.

    The group has hired Messrs UHY Diong as its special auditor.

    In 2001, Ishak was fined RM400,000 by the Sessions Court for giving false information to the SC.

    A former politician, he was once involved in a battle with the Lau brothers for control of KFC. Ishak was firmly in control of KFC until the Asian financial crisis hit Malaysia in 1997.
    Kenmark also named new directors yesterday. They are executive chairman Datuk Abd Gani Yusof, executive director Ho Soo Woon, and independent non-executive directors Ahmed Azhar Abdullah and Woon Wai En.

    Kenmark's independent directors Zainabon @ Zainab Abu Bakar and Yeunh Wee Tiong have tendered their resignations yesterday. (why ah?)

    "The new directors are currently assessing the current situation of the Kenmark Group and are in discussion with the receivers of Kenmark Paper Sdn Bhd to allow the re-activation of business operations at the business and corporate office at Port Klang soonest possible and restore market confidence," Kenmark said in a statement to Bursa Malaysia.

    The new directors also stressed that all employees have been paid salaries up to May 2010 and all payments to statutory bodies have also been made.

    On June 2, Kenmark said Hwang fell ill in China from May 24 and he could not be reached as his family barred all calls. The group's new directors hope that he could return by next month.

    As for the other two Taiwanese directors, Chang Chin-Chuan and Chen Wen-Ling who were also said to be missing, they have made contact with Kenmark. (so why they went missing? why ah?)

    Shares of Kenmark have been suspended since June 2 and its last traded price was 11.5 sen.

    Read more: Ishak now a major investor in Kenmark
    here

Many would be SIMPLY DISGUTIBATED with what they had just read!

Biggest question, is how much did Ishak bought the shares??? Who are the sellers????

Think about it.....

Here we have a share that was trading around 90 sen. Perhaps it was grossly over priced at 90 sen given the state of its business fundamentals, in which its poor balance sheet was clearly visible.

But the news that a willing buyer (friendly some more) suddenly appear just stinks the whole place up once again.

If the buyer was willing why didn't the buyer buy much earlier? Couldn't he bought on 31st May?

Why wait until the shit hit the ceiling? ( Nice to buy cheap, eh?)

Why isn't the sale and purchase of the shares more transparent?

This was all in the announcement posted on Bursa website: All it states is Ishak bought 20 million shares on 2nd June and 10 million shares on 1st June. Link here and here. And Unioncity Enterprises Ltd purchased 27.6 million shares. Why no price stated?

If it's an open market trade, surely people would accuse that the bad news ( chatter that apparently the MD had ran away due to banks demanding their money back ) drove the stock to almost worthless at 3.5 sen and now that the stock sank so low, a friendly buyer miraculously appeared to save the day.

Surely we are not talking about Robin Hoods here!

And to compound the matters worst, Kenmark shares miraculously rallied on the 2nd.

Yeah, later on that day, the market learned about the incredible Kenmark: Sorry But I Was Sick excuse!

Gee how nice people!

30 million shares purchased when the shares plunged into the abyss.

Go figure if Kenmark shares rallies higher.

What a wonderful capitalist world.

But seriously.... is this allowed?

Can SC allow all this?

And oh Bursa, what happen to all the QUALITY listing talk. Comeon... stopped thinking from a business perspective and keep on churning out stocks like this on the exchange. Quantity matters not when all the investing public get is mess like this.

On Star Business:

Kenmark still has not submitted its earnings. How? Any hanky panky? Why did the incredible surge in receivables happen? Receivables totals 248 million! What if these receivables cannot be collected? Provision of bad debts? ( see Kenmark: MD and Deputy GM 'resigns', Share Plummets Big Time!!! )

And mind you, this is a massive time bomb. If Kenmark does not submit soon, it would be suspended yet again.

And last but not least... in the Star article Ishak is Kenmark’s biggest stakeholder

  • “James (the MD) called me on Monday night to help him out as he is sick. This is the company we both floated in 1997 when I was the bumiputra shareholder. However, I sold my shares a long time ago,’’ he told StarBiz

Monday night?

In the posting Kenmark: Sorry But I Was Sick

  • "James Hwang in his letter has stated that he has been unwell and unconscious and was also uncontactable. He has now regained full consciousness but still physically weak," said the company in a statement to Bursa Malaysia on Wednesday, June 2.
  • "It was only yesterday (Tuesday) I regained full consciousness but am still weak to travel," he said. He did not identify the nature of the sickness nor did he say when he expects to be well.Hwang will only return to Malaysia once he is healthy.Hwang also said he could not be reached by telephone as all calls had been barred by family members.

Sorry I am confused.

Ishak got the call on Monday night. If James Hwang was in China, say Beijing, the time zone would be the same as here, yes? So can I assume Monday night as in Monday night Malaysia time?

And James Hwang states he only regained consciousness on Tuesday.

Hmmm..... how?

And Ishak bought 20 million shares on Monday. See Link here

How now Brown Cow?

Read more...

Kenmark: Sorry But I Was Sick

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

I can't go to school... I am sick!!!

Isn't that your favourite excuse not to go to school?

But when you hear the MD... sorry... no the ex-MD using this excuse... it's really, really, really pathetic. Who's kidding who?

Ok.. perhaps I was being nasty there. Perhaps he is legitimately sick but do consider the following facts... let me paste from a news clip..

On May 12, the company revealed that EXIM Bank had issued letters of demand to:

  • Kenmark’s wholly owned subsidiary Billion Dynamic Sdn Bhd for a sum of RM43.77 million for failing to regularise a credit facility of RM40 million;

  • Kenmark itself which stands as a guarantor to Billion Dynamic;

  • Kenmark’s subsidiary in Labuan, Kenmark (Labuan) Ltd, for US$1.69 million (RM5.51 million) for failing to regularise an overseas project financing facility amounting to US$6.5 million; and

  • Kenmark itself for an amount of RM15.91 million for a credit facility of RM15 million.

Lot's of money owed to the bank and the bank is knocking at the door.

On May 28th,

  • The company stated that it received on Friday, May 28, 2010 a letter of demand from EON Bank for the sum of RM7.67 million for defaulting on banking facilities.

On May 31st,

  • KENMARK INDUSTRIAL CO. (M) BHD independent directors Zainab Abu Bakar and Yeunh Wee Tiong have informed Bursa Securities that the managing director James Hwang and deputy general manager Goh Kim Chon have resigned from the company

Share tumbles big time.... with huge volume too. (Hmm... don't you wonder? )

Yesterday... Kenmark MD says he was unwell, unconscious (ps.. Kenmark shares rallied big time)

  • KUALA LUMPUR:KENMARK INDUSTRIAL CO. (M) BHD []'s independent directors had received an email from the managing director that Hwang Ding Kuo @ James Hwang, had been unwell and unconscious, hence uncontactable.

    "James Hwang in his letter has stated that he has been unwell and unconscious and was also uncontactable. He has now regained full consciousness but still physically weak," said the company in a statement to Bursa Malaysia on Wednesday, June 2.

    Kenmark said Hwang proposed the appointment of Ho Soo Woon, Ahmed Azhar Abdullah, Woon Wai En, Datuk Abd. Gani Yusof to manage the issues that have arisen in his absence. Two are proposed to be Executive Directors.

    "The independent directors will convene a meeting tomorrow morning by teleconference with the Taiwanese directors to consider the appointment and make the necessary announcement," it said.

Here's the Business Times version.

  • The group's boss and major shareholder, Hwang Ding Kuo@James Hwang, says he will only return to Malaysia once he is healthy

    Kenmark Industrial Co (M) Bhd (7030) said its boss and major shareholder, who was missing as the group's fortunes took a rapid turn for the worse, is sick in China.

    In a statement sent to Bursa Malaysia through the company's secretary yesterday, Hwang Ding Kuo@James Hwang said he was taken ill in China on May 24 and was in a delirious state.

    "It was only yesterday (Tuesday) I regained full consciousness but am still weak to travel," he said. He did not identify the nature of the sickness nor did he say when he expects to be well.

    Hwang will only return to Malaysia once he is healthy.
    Hwang also said he could not be reached by telephone as all calls had been barred by family members.

    However, he said a friendly party has bought a substantial stake in the company and new appointment of directors will be made, including two executive directors to manage the current situation.

    Hwang did not give details of the deal.

    "I wish to state I am still the managing director of Kenmark and will work together with the new shareholder to try and resolve all outstanding issues caused by my sudden absence," Hwang said.

    He also did not state the current whereabouts of two other Taiwanese executive directors Chang Chin-Chuan and Chen Wen-Ling who were also said to be missing.

    The new directors to be appointed are Ho Soo Woon, Ahmed Azhar Abdullah, Woon Wai En and Abdul Gani Yusof.

    They will also review the company's situation in Vietnam.

    "I have spoken to Ho to have him discuss with Bursa Securities for a time extension to announce the fourth quarter results and appoint a special auditor," Hwang said.

    Over on the stock market, Kenmark's shares were suspended at 4.43pm yesterday and they will remain so indefinitely, according to Bursa Malaysia.

    Before the suspension, its shares were among the most active when it almost doubled to 11.5 sen from 6 sen previously
    .

    Since news broke that Hwang went missing, Kenmark lost as much as RM140 million in stock market value in a matter of days while more than 400 of its workers were uncertain about their future.

    Even the Securities Commission will investigate the furniture maker, while Bursa Malaysia directed Kenmark to appoint a special auditor to probe its finances.

    Kenmark's shocking story started on May 31 when its shares tumbled 68 per cent, leading to a query from Bursa Malaysia.
    The group said that its two independent directors could not contact Hwang while key executives have quit.

    It also cannot issue the fourth quarter results for the period to March 31 2010.

    The independent directors were told by former executives that all of its operations have stopped while two banks demanded some RM73 million of their money back.

    To make matters worse, it immediately became a PN17 company, a label of financially troubled firms on Bursa Malaysia.

    Meanwhile, Kenmark's external company secretary Leong Oi Wah when contacted confirmed the independent directors will still meet with the company's receiver, PricewaterhouseCoopers, as planned on Friday to
    determine the actual debt of the company.

    Read more: Kenmark: MD in China, is sick
    http://www.btimes.com.my/Current_News/BTIMES/articles/kenmak4-2/Article/#ixzz0pkAwUlJ6

Ok.. I will be fair and attempt to decipher the Business Times article...

1. First bankers demanded some 72 million back from Kenmark.

2. Then Kenmark said the MD resigned.

3. Kenmark MD said he's sick. Was unconscious. Only woke up yesterday.

4. MD does NOT state what sickness that caused him to be unconscious.

5. But... you cannot call him. Apparently family members barred all calls.

6. Two executive directors from Taiwan has gone missing. MD did not state where they were.

7. Apparently... a friendly party has bought a huge stake in the company. (hmm.. no changes of shareholders announcement made on Bursa. hmmm...... stock rallied yesterday (many did not know why))

8. Company has NOT released its earnings.

9. Company is now a PN17 stock and is currently suspended (yeah.. after surging like crazy yesterday!)

10. Pricewaterhouse is contacted to determine the actual debts of the company.

11. MD will only return back to Malaysia when he is healthy. Apparently he's too sick to travel.

How?

Well.. my name is not Susan. :D

Do you buy what's being said?

Read more...

Did Bank Of America And Citigroup Commit Accounting Fraud?

Friday, May 28, 2010

On CNBC:


  • Bank of America and Citigroup incorrectly accounted for billions of dollars in debt over the past three years, according to a report from the Wall Street Journal.

    The report highlights a form of corporate borrowing increasingly under scrutiny since the financial crisis began. The loans, known as "repos," or short-term repurchase agreements, allow banks to increase the amount of risk they can take in securities trading.

    Both BofA [BAC 15.74 -0.44 (-2.72%) ] and Citigroup [C 3.96 -0.06 (-1.49%) ] disclosed in filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission that they have over the last three years accidentally classified some repos as sales when they should have been classified as borrowings, the newspaper reported. The amounts involved were small for the banks, though they totaled billions....
    http://www.cnbc.com/id/37366067

The WSJ article..

WSJ: Bank Of America, Citigroup Incorrectly Hid Billions In Repo Debt

  • Bank of America Corp. (BAC) and Citigroup Inc. (C) incorrectly hid from investors billions of dollars of their debt, similar to what Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. did to obscure its level of risk, company documents show.

    In recent filings with regulators, the two big banks disclosed that over the past three years, they at times erroneously classified some short-term repurchase agreements, or "repos," as sales when they should have been classified as borrowings. Though the classifications involved billions of dollars, they represented relatively small amounts for the banks.

    (This story and related background material will be available on The Wall Street Journal Web site, WSJ.com.)

    A bankruptcy-court examiner said Lehman had been doing the same thing to make its balance sheet look better before it filed for bankruptcy in September 2008, using a strategy dubbed "Repo 105" that helped the Wall Street firm move $50 billion in assets off its balance sheet.

    Bank of America and Citigroup say their misclassifications were due to errors--not an attempt to make themselves look less risky, which examiner Anton Valukas said was Lehman's motivation. The disclosures, made after federal securities regulators began asking financial firms about their repo accounting, were included in quarterly filings earlier this month but not highlighted.

    The disclosures come amid a series of revelations about how banks obscure their risk-taking before reporting their finances to the public, a practice known in the financial world as "window dressing."

    Bank of America and Citigroup were among the banks cited in a page-one Wall Street Journal article on Wednesday detailing how financial firms temporarily shed repo debt at the ends of quarters, when they report their finances to investors. Since the financial crisis began, both banks often have reduced their quarter-end repo debt from their average borrowings for the same quarter. That activity didn't involve misclassifying repo loans as sales.

    Repos are short-term loans that allow banks to take bigger risks on securities trades; classifying the transactions as sales instead of borrowings allows a firm to take assets off its balance sheet and thus reduces its reported leverage, or assets as a multiple of equity capital.

    Federal securities rules bar financial firms from intentionally masking debt to deceive investors. There is no indication that Bank of America or Citigroup misclassified their repos intentionally or that the Securities and Exchange Commission will take any action against them. An SEC spokesman declined to comment.

    The amounts Bank of America and Citigroup cite are relatively small. The misclassifications had tiny impacts on the banks' reported leverage, and none at all on their earnings or shareholder equity. The banks didn't restate any financial statements.

    Bank of America said the misclassified transactions in certain quarters over the past three years-ranging from $573 million to as much as $10.7 billion-"represented substantially less than 1% of our total assets" and had no material impact on its balance sheet, earnings or borrowing ratios.

    Citigroup said the misclassified transactions-of $5.7 billion as of the end of 2009, and as much as $9.2 billion over the past three years-involved "a very limited number of our business units" that "used this type of transaction in very small amounts." It also said its errors were immaterial to its financial statements. "At no point in time was the impact of these sales transactions large enough to have a noticeable impact on our published leverage ratios."

    By comparison, both banks have more than $2 trillion in assets.

    The SEC had asked big banks in March for more information about their repo accounting in the wake of the Lehman bankruptcy report. That inquiry hasn't found any widespread inappropriate practices, SEC Chief Accountant James Kroeker told a congressional subcommittee last week.

    But Kroeker said the SEC has asked several companies to provide more disclosure about their repo accounting in their securities filings. Bank of America and Citigroup indicated they had found their errors on their own initiative.

    More broadly, the SEC is now considering stricter disclosure and a clearer rationale from firms about quarter-end borrowing activities. The agency may extend these rules to all companies, not just banks. The potential new rules, disclosed by SEC Chairman Mary Schapiro at a congressional hearing last month, came two weeks after the Journal's initial article about banks' debt-masking activity.

    Separately, Bank of New York Mellon Corp. (BK) said in a securities filing that it had found some small errors in its repo accounting over the past three years. The bank said it didn't use Repo 105 transactions.

    The errors have been corrected, and none of them were material to the bank's financial statements, the bank said in the filing. A Bank of New York Mellon spokesman declined further comment.

So CNBC version is incorrectly account... WSJ version was incorrectly hid...

LOL!

Sigh!

So what was at stake?

The amount of debts.

Surely... the amount of debts in a balance sheet is so very crucial for the investor in the street, yes? How can the banks incorrectly account/hid these figures?

Yes it might had no financial impact to the banks earnings but the balance sheet did look better than what it really was had these debts been accounted correctly!

Would it be piss wrong to accuse that this is pure financial shenanigans?

Or would it be wrong to call it fraud?

And these banks are trying to dismiss it as small amount.

My... it's only BILLION of dollars worth of incorrectness!

My.... good or what!

Read more...

  © Blogger templates Newspaper by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP