Powered by Blogger.

Home

Showing posts with label LCCT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LCCT. Show all posts

MSWG Also Questions The Need For New LCCT!!

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Posted the other day: Does Two LCT Makes Sense? and More On Sime Darby's Labu LCT Project.

Today on Business Times, MSWG also addresses this very same issue!
MSWG questions need for new LCCT

  • The Minority Shareholder Watchdog Group (MSWG) has questioned the benefits of the new low-cost carrier terminal (LCCT) in Labu, Negri Sembilan, proposed by Sime Darby Bhd and AirAsia Bhd.

    "Under the current depressed market conditions and likely difficult times ahead, initiatives led by the private sectors are most welcomed. Nonetheless, all key stakeholders must look at the broader picture to benefit the nation as a whole and the companies specifically," its new chief executive officer Rita Benoy Bushon said in a statement yesterday.

    She said while there may be persuasive arguments for Sime Darby and AirAsia to build a new LCCT, the watchdog group believes that an "orderly development and construction of airports and aviation infrastructure in the country must be given the utmost consideration to ensure optimisation of resources in line with the country's National Airport Masterplan".

    "(While) it is good to have competition, whether there is room for two LCCTs to be developed is debatable," she added.

    Bushon also questioned the funding arrangements and ownership of the proposed LCCT.
    These are important for shareholders to assess the impact on the companies' gearing and cash flow.

    "At MSWG, we believe in the board of directors' duty of making decisions to the best interest of their companies, shareholders and stakeholders.

    "We also believe that commercial viability, merits of competition and value-creation should be at the heart of any corporate decision," she added.

    MSWG believes that the proposed LCCT will hurt airport operator Malaysia Airports Holdings Bhd as it will cannibalise the existing capacity of KLIA given that AirAsia commands 16 per cent and 49 per cent of the international passenger and domestic passenger movements respectively at the airport.

    Last month, the Cabinet gave its consent for Sime Darby and AirAsia to proceed with the proposed LCCT on Sime Darby's 2,800ha in Labu. The two companies are now in preliminary discussions with the state and federal authorities.

Well done Rita!

Take AirAsia involvement posted in the other blog posting: More Capital Borrowing For AirAsia????

Bottom line is AirAsia is already buried way deep in debts but yet it wants to borrow more to involve in the building of the LCCT terminal.

Does it even make sense?

Is this how a business is run?

Is money really that cheap that one can borrow and borrow and borrow??????

Read more...

Does Two LCCT Makes Sense?

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Blogged the other day: More On Sime Darby's Labu LCCT Project.

I made the following set of comments.

  • That's my point.

    Why can't they just make only one LCCT?

    To have two LCCT makes no sense at all.

    And to have one at Labu is even horrendous reasoning!

    Doesn't it defeats all logical reasoning for air travellers who seek lower air fares?

    How much would it take for these budget air travellers to travel to Labu to board their cheap flights? As it is, the airport at Sepang isn't too popular since it's already located so far from the city of KL. And now they want to make the LCCT at even a further location at Labu?

    Imagine if Labu is constructed... and nobody showed up? Not possible? Won't air travellers avoid Labu because of its location?

Aseambankers today came up with a research note on this issue.

Here is a screenshot of what they said.




Read more...

More On Sime Darby's Labu LCT Project.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Blogged yesterday: So Many New LCT Terminals For Malaysia?

Fellow blogger Dali had written a piece also on Sime Darby,
I No Longer Friend Sime Darby



  • b) New Low Cost Terminal @ Labu - The new terminal, to be called "KLIA East @ Labu", will be built on a 2,800 hectare site (6,919 acres) in Negeri Sembilan under a private finance initiative, costing RM1.6 billion (US$461 million). Labu is between Nilai and Seremban. The project is to be undertaken jointly by Air Asia and Sime Darby.

    Firstly, simple planning will reveal that we need a phase 1, phase 2 and phase 3 for the current LCT to cope with organic growth and demand, not just by AA but other budget carriers... just zone off a piece of land 4-5x the current size and make sure expansion phases do not hinder current operations - why no planning, why the sudden need to have a new second LCT. If we had planned better in the first place, we would not have needed the second one so soon - I do not like to trash the authorities, but please la, this is planning and budgeting 101.

    Secondly, why suddenly Sime Darby is roped in? This is not Sime's expertise, especially when there is a more relevant body in Malaysia Airports Holding - what is the under-current, why do we pick and choose and allow ourselves to be lobbied into inefficiences.
    Apparently, Sime is involved because the new LCT will be an integral part of its proposed development plan for its Negeri Sembilan Vision City ("NSVC"). NSVC is part of the Company's Central Vision Valley ("CVV") property development project spanning Selangor and Negeri Sembilan.

    Now, lets hear what Malaysia Airports Holdings Bhd (MAHB) has just said " MAHB implied that it is more logical for the Low Cost Carrier Terminal (LCCT) to be at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport (KLIA)". In a statement today, the airport operator said it is now in a position to undertake the project with its own funds, thanks to the government’s approved restructuring plan. The National Airport Master Plan study, after considering several locations, has identified a site for the permanent LCCT at KLIA, MAHB said. The new LCCT location was selected as it would provide excellent connectivity for both landside and airside transfers for passengers as well as baggage. At least there is a National Airport Master Plan, why the need for so many LCTs, why can't MAHB be allowed to build a really big one next to KLIA, maybe the new LCT can have its own runway as we
    .
Well put!

I fully agree on this part.

  • just zone off a piece of land 4-5x the current size and make sure expansion phases do not hinder current operations - why no planning, why the sudden need to have a new second LCT. If we had planned better in the first place, we would not have needed the second one so soon - I do not like to trash the authorities, but please la, this is planning and budgeting 101.

That's my point.

Why can't they just make only one LCT?

To have two LCT makes no sense at all.

And to have one at Labu is even horrendous reasoning!

Doesn't it defeats all logical reasoning for air travellers who seek lower air fares?

How much would it take for these budget air travellers to travel to Labu to board their cheap flights? As it is, the airport at Sepang isn't too popular since it's already located so far from the city of KL. And now they want to make the LCT at even a further location at Labu?

Imagine if Labu is constructed... and nobody showed up? Not possible? Won't air travellers avoid Labu because of its location?

Read more...

So Many New LCT Terminals For Malaysia?

Monday, January 5, 2009

I do not understand the justifications.

Published on Star Business:
Go-ahead for Sime Darby and MAHB terminals

  • PETALING JAYA: Even as Sime Darby Bhd announced it has received government approval to proceed with the proposed private low-cost carrier terminal (LCCT) project in Labu, Negri Sembilan, Malaysia Airports Holdings Bhd (MAHB) gave some details of its plans to develop a new LCCT at the KL International Airport (KLIA).

    MAHB managing director Datuk Seri Bashir Ahmad told StarBiz: “We still need to provide an LCCT at KLIA for airlines other than AirAsia that will fly into Kuala Lumpur.

    “As a GLC (government-linked company), we will talk to the government on our plans for the future, with regards to the LCCT.”

    MAHB said it has identified a location of for the permanent LCCT at KLIA.

    “The new LCCT location (near KLIA) was selected as it would provide excellent connectivity for both landside and airside transfers for passengers as well as baggage,”
    it said in a statement yesterday.

    As for the existing LCCT, Bashir said: “This was always ment to be temporary, we will convert it into a warehouse.”

    On whether MAHB’s LCCT project at KLIA would be scaled down as AirAsia would now use the terminal to be built in Labu, Bashir said: “We will have to see about this when we discuss (this) with the government.”

    Sime Darby is also a GLC with its major shareholders being Skim Amanah Saham Bumiputera with a 34% stake while the Employees Provident Fund, Permodalan Nasional Bhd and Yayasan Pelaburan Bumiputera has about 14% each, as at Sept 12 last year.

    Sime Darby in a statement to Bursa Malaysia yesterday said its LCCT project was an integral part of its Negri Sembilan Vision City (NSVC) project.

    NSVC is part of its Central Vision Valley (CVV) property development project spanning Selangor and Negri Sembilan.

    Sime Darby and budget airline AirAsia Bhd had proposed to jointly develop and operate the privately funded RM1.6bil LCCT to be known as KLIA-East@Labu.

    Meanwhile, MAHB in its statement yesterday said the terminal congestion at the existing LCCT would ease with the recent opening of the newly expanded international arrival hall and the soon to be completed international departure hall and public concourse.

    “To further alleviate the congestion, MAHB has appealed to AirAsia to open up more check-in counters per flight as there are many available at the LCCT.

    “MAHB has also urged AirAsia to provide additional ground handling staff for arrival baggage as there are now six carousels at the arrival hall instead of two previously,” the statement said.

    MAHB, noting AirAsia’s request for a reduction in aeronautical charges, clarified that the charges were approved by the Government and that this was a matter for the government authorities to decide.

    “Any increases or decreases in these charges are within the purview of the Government authorities and MAHB fully respects this.

    “It needs to be emphasised that the landing and parking charges in Malaysia have not been increased for the last 27 years.

    “Therefore, the issue of high aeronautical charges does not arise,” it said.

Two LCT terminals??

Is this even economically feasible for our country?

Read more...

  © Blogger templates Newspaper by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP