Powered by Blogger.

Home

Showing posts with label Featured Report KN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Featured Report KN. Show all posts

KN Downgrades P&O To A Hold!!

Thursday, December 2, 2010

They said the stock was cheap. It was trading only at 3x earnings only.

They said the stock had potential because 'the owner was contemplating a divestment in P&O in a deal that could reap proceeds that were well above P&O’s implied stock market valuations.'

And so with all these 'right' ingredients, the stock flew up, up and away. ( Chart belows shows P&O when the posting, Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit, was made on 31st July 2010)


The local media added more fuel by publishing the following article. Prudential UK eyes P&O takeover

Since then... the Prudential deal was discontinued without much explanation. ( Here's P&O announcement: Proposed divestment of an equity interest in Pacific & Orient Insurance Co. Bhd. )

And the cheapness in earnings?

KN blasted out loud that P&O could earn some 32.87 million for fy 2010, when the company was sitting on half year losses of 1.4 million. However, it did not based P&O target price based on its earnings estimate of 32.87 million but it based it on fy 2011's earnings estimates of 43.47 million!!!! And KN based the 3x earnings cheapness on that 43.47 million! ( See Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit , And So P&O Earnings Are Said To Be Inline With Expectations and For which fiscal year did P&O earned more than 30 million? )

P&O reported its Q4 earnings last week. Its 2010 earnings came in at some 21 million.

KN's estimate again? 32.87 million for fy 2010 and 43.47 million for fy 2011.

So naturally, the earnings was way, way below estimates.

Meanwhile the stock....



Ahem...

How?

And not forgetting in the middle of all this.... a 10% private placement was done...

Some 'interesting' comments from KN from its reported dated 1st Dec 2010.

  • Disappointing quarter with full year net profit of RM21.3m (65% of our RM32.9m estimates) due to a huge set back from unexpectedly high effective tax rate of 50% thus dragging group’s performance. During the quarter, the group took a RM8.7m reversal of it’s deferred tax assets that saw DTA down to RM5.8m from 3QFY10 of RM14.5m and hence contributed to higher than expected tax expenses. However, pretax profit of RM42.3m was inline with our forecast of RM43.8m.

Ahem... 65% of our RM32.9 estimates...

  • We are taking conservative stance after a dismal FY10. FY11F is reduced 21% to RM34.6m and 28% for FY12 PAT of RM37.7m as we reduce our premium sales assumption to 6-8% from 15% previously.

Conservative stance? FY2011 is reduced 21% to rm34.6million??!!! LOL!

  • Target price is reduced to RM0.84 (from RM1.15 previously) based on 6x FY11 while recommendation is also reduced to a HOLD from BUY previously. This values the group at 6x revised FY11 EPS of 14.06sen, which is at the low end of the 6-15x 2010/11 PER of Malaysian general insurers.

Target price is reduced to rm 0.84?!! LOL!

Actually, by itself, P&O performance for this year had been incredible. I have to say that. Take a look at the posting For which fiscal year did P&O earned more than 30 million? again.

P&O 2010's earnings of 21.3 million is the best ever performance from then since 2000.

But the way KN declared the cheapness in the stock was really something else.



Read more...

For which fiscal year did P&O earned more than 30 million?

Thursday, August 26, 2010

In the posting And So P&O Earnings Are Said To Be Inline With Expectations, I asked a very simple question.

  • For which fiscal year did P&O earned more than 30 million?

Why was this question asked?

Let's roll back.

On 31st July 2010, I wrote Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit and I highlighted P&O amazing buy call from Kenanga Research.






Remember, KN's buy call was based on FY11 earnings.

  • 92% upside to base case valuation of RM 1.15. This values the group at an undemanding FY11 PER of 6x.

Yes we need to ask ourselves how muchie is that said earnings estimate. Answer: 43.47 million.

Why?

Because if the said earnings is too optimistic, then........ ? :P

So back to my question:

  • For which fiscal year did P&O earned more than 30 million?

Here's my complied table (from Bursa website - pls feel free to verify data cos I could always make a mistake. :D )


Now I could have used data from 2000. That would have been a sufficient guide. And my answer for that question would have been P&O have never earned more than 30 million this decade. Yes, since 2000, P&O have never earned more than 30 million!

Yes.. past data does not guarantee that the future would be the same but.... some serious consideration have to be taken into account, which is P&O has not earned more than 30 million since 2000. And here is K&N, telling the investing public that P&O is cheap because it can earn some 43.47 million.

oO

!!!!!

Exactly!

And yes, to be fair, P&O did earn some 68.325 for its fy 1999. That was the only time P&O earned more than 30 million, as per the earnings report on Bursa website. That's one year in a span of 12 years that P&O earned more than 30 mil!

How?

And yes, I am aware that ..... sometimes... there are days when earnings and fundamentals just doesn't matter. :D

And yeah, some would quickly correct my flawed ways by saying... P&O rally won't be based on earnings.

It's all about the potential M&A.

Ah... yes... potential M&A's makes stocks very interesting.

Stocks won't be valued in the shambolic ketam way using low PE earnings valuations like when the owners turn priate and privatised their listed stocks. In fact most of the time, they used the 'premium over current traded price' as the valuation method.

No sir!

M&A are so very the special.

They are priced to whatever best possible valuation they could think off.

Hey... willing buyer, willing seller. :D

Hey look at the other ketam stock. They went into collaboration talks only. And the share price doubled! LOL! Love the market yo!


Past postings:

  1. 31 July 2010: Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit
  2. 2 Aug 2010: P&O: And The Flying Stock Soars Even Higher!
  3. 21 Aug 2010: And So P&O Reported Its Earnings
  4. 25 Aug 2010: And So P&O Earnings Are Said To Be Inline With Expectations

Read more...

Featured Report: K&N On Sino Hua-An Part II

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

It's about an year ago, 18 Aug 2009, I wrote the following posting: Featured Report: Kenanga On Sino Hua-An

Let me highlight what I wrote then..... >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Last night Hua-An's lost some 13.279 million and year-to-date losses were 36.911 million.

And Hua-An stock price is also 0.545. :p2

Despite losing money, Kenanga insist that the prospect is bright! (losing less money is good eh?)



Viola!

Kenanga still have a buy on Sino Hua-An but with a lower target price.

Yeah.. losing less money is good. :D

So who wants Hua-An?

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Today... Sino Sua-An price is at 35 sen and Sino Hua An is finally making money!

Yes, Sino Hua An announced profits in its quarterly earnings notes last night. It made a profit of 4.844 million for the quarter and year-to-date, Sino Hua-An made some 2.362 million!

Guess what is K&N's recommendation today?

SELL!

Yes you heard me correct. It's a SELL with a target price of 0.26 sen!

LOL!

In short... :P

Aug 2009: Sino Hua An made less losses! (yes less losses) and Hua An was at 0.545. K&N called it a BUY with a target price of 0.63.

Aug 2010: Sino Hua An finally made money and Hua An is at 0.35. K&N now calls it a SELL with a target price of 0.26!

Now correct me if I am wrong here but isn't K&N suggesting that Sino Hua An is only worth a BUY when it's losing money? ( :p2 )




How?

Me?

I just LOVE this game!

:D

Read more...

And So P&O Earnings Are Said To Be Inline With Expectations

And so I said the following in the blog posting And So P&O Reported Its Earnings

  • P&O announced its earnings last night. It said it made some 11.072 million. Earlier in the posting on P&O: Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit, I noted that P&O had a half year losses of 1.417 million, which means P&O's total 3 quarters earnings for current fiscal year is 9.66 million.

    K&N estimates for current fiscal year is 32.87 million!

    LOL!

    Which means P&O have to double their earnings for the last quarter of this fiscal year to 23.2 million 'JUST' to be in-line with K&N's estimates!

    WakaWaka! Huhu!

And since K&N had been the champion for the stock, I guess it's only fair I highlight what they are saying.

  • P&O’s 3QFY10 results were inline with our expectations. Overall sales were relatively strong and claims were modest.

Inline within their expectations? Their fy 2010 expectations was 32.87 million. P&O only did 11.072 million for 3 quarters.

Like this also they BOLDLY claim that P&O earnings were inline with their expectations??

LOL!

Good or what! :P

I then held my breath and continued.

K&N then claimed that P&O earnings were actually lower... because ... of the absence of the write back of allowance for diminution in value of earnings. LOL!

  • 3QFY10 revenue of RM109.7m was up by +22% YoY vs. 3QFY09 of RM89.6m. YTD, the group has achieved total sales of RM360.1m or 25.6% YoY. We believe both increases were mainly attributable to higher gross premium recorded and continued capture market share in motorcycle segment. Lower net profit of RM11.1m (-56.9% Yoy) was mainly attributable to the absence of write back of allowance for diminution in value of investments in the current quarter.

And then K&N recognise that they are way behind its earning estimates for P&O.

  • Despite 9M’s profit of RM9.7m at only 29.4% of our forecast, we understand that the annual net profit would only be known by final quarter after the actuary testing on IBNR reserve in 4Q. Based on our estimates and guidance, it is highly likely that the group will be able to exceed our FY10 net profit forecast of RM32.9m.

I do hope you and I read it correctly. :D

Despite 9m profit of 9.7m at only 29.4% of their forecast, K&N remains positive and they feel it is highly likely P&O will able to exceed their FY 2010 net profit forecast of 32.9 million.

And K&N's earnings valuation of P&O. (ah.. this is important... cos if the Prudential talks does not turn out... this is what you are left with.)

  • We maintain our base case valuation of RM1.15. This values the group at an undemanding FY11 PER of 6x, which is at the low end of the 6-15x 2010/11 PER of Malaysian general insurers.

ROFLOL!

See this is where and how the 'beat the expectation' games is played.

As can be seen, K&N admits that P&O's CURRENT earnings is way behind its expectations. It's only 29.4% of its expectation.

29.4%.

And its expectation is already 32.9 million.

Which is rather high, yes?

But... but.... but.... K&N is NOT using this set of numbers!

YES!

K&N is not even using 32.9 million!

K&N's valuation is based on fy 2011 numbers!

And as pointed out in the posting Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit, K&N's earnings estimate for P&O fy 2011 is ................................................ 43.47 million!!!!!!



oO

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LOL!

Yup, as it is... P&O is only 29.4% of K&N's earnings estimate of 32.9 million.

And the fair value of P&O is 1.15. This is based on earnings valuations on the assumption that P&O can earning a whopping 43.47 million!!!

yes, my dearest, this is how the beat the earnings estimate game is played!

ps: Here's a question: For which fiscal year did P&O earned more than 30 million?

Past postings:

Read more...

Regarding P&O: The Stock That Flew Into Orbit

Friday, July 30, 2010

Saw the following article on Star Business: Prudential UK eyes P&O takeover

Now before I read what the article was saying, I was aware that K&N had dona a stock analysis (initiated coverage) on the stock back on 22nd July 2010 and I was well aware that the stock literally flew into the orbit.

Yeah... you know and I know... if you are reading this right now... LOL!... you are rather LATE into the party.

Don't believe?

Think I am being nasty and so black hearted and I am attempting to stop you from seeking next week's fortunes in the stock market? Well take a look...




The stock was just 0.585 sen on 21 Jul 2010. The stock last traded at 0.925 on Friday. (ps: K&N initiated coverage on P&O when the stock was trading at 63 sen. Target price stated was 1.65!! :D)

And so after the stock is well into orbit, the local media is only promoting the stock now.

How?

Could it go much higher?

And how high?

:D

I then proceeded to read what the mighty pen from our local press has to write...

  • PETALING JAYA: Prudential UK is believed to have submitted an application to Bank Negara to commence talks on the potential acquisition of local general insurance company, Pacific & Orient Bhd (P&O).

    However, the details of the potential merger and acquisition (M&A) exercise between the two parties were still unclear....

'Is believed'? LOL! Who is believing this? And yeah... details of the M&A is... STILL UNCLEAR!

LOL!

  • This has added fuel to recent market talk that P&O had emerged on the radar of potential buyers.

Well? This Star 'financial' news article is sure adding the fuel! :D

  • According to Kenanga Research, the owner was contemplating a divestment in P&O in a deal that could reap proceeds that were well above P&O’s implied stock market valuations.

    Chan Thye Seng, the managing director and chief executive officer of P&O, holds a 51.4% stake in the company.

    When contacted, P&O declined to comment on the matter.

    When contacted, a spokesperson from Prudential Malaysia said it did not comment on market speculation.

Ah.. the K&N article ( let's see that later ) ... but ... how ironic... here we have a stock that is flying off into the orbit... and the two parties speculated to be involved in a M&A is declining to comment on the..... market speculation.

LOL!

  • “Having undergone a massive change in business direction over the last two years, P&O has engineered a major turnaround in profitability,” said Kenanga in a recent report.
    P&O returned to the black in the previous financial year ended Sept 30, 2009, with a net profit of RM14.9mil compared with a net loss of RM32.6mil the year before.

    But, for the first six months of the current financial year, P&O slipped back into the red with a net loss of RM1.4mil compared with a net loss of RM6.1mil in the previous corresponding period.

Ah... A turnaround stock... but ... but... but... it's conflicting... :P

Look at what K&N is saying... 2008 it was losing money.. 2009 it returned to the black.. BUT.. the first half of the year... P&O is losing money again.

How would you define it?

Me?

I see a possible turnaround.. but...with P&O losing money again the first half of the current fiscal year.. I reckon it would be best that I not used that word 'turnaround'... and I would certainly not boldly call it 'a “ major turnaround in profitability” like how K&N did.

  • As at March 30, 2010, its net asset per share was RM1.34.
    P&O’s main focus is on two core areas – financial services and information technology (IT).

Huhu!

Net asset per share was rm 1.34 as at 30th March 2010?? LOL! K&N Target price is 1.65! More than the net asset per share! No wonder this stock is so 'powderful' the past couple of days. :D

(ps: buy on rumours? Sell on news? :P )

Time to dig out that K&N report... (ps: this is a 15 page report. The longer the better eh? :P )


  • Extremely cheap valuations. P&O is trading at 3x FY11 PER and 0.55x P/BV. There could be upside to our profit forecasts as our investment assumptions of 2.5% Fixed Deposit yields are fairly prudent to account for its RM900m near cash holding.

Huhu!

rm900 million near cash holding??????

Where are all the 'value investors'?

Time to check out some announcements on Bursa website.. ( ahh.. recently.. a stock split Entitlement - Others )

Here's P&O quarterly earnings reported in May 2010: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/3/2010

Here's a screenshot of its balance sheet asset...


hmm.. maybe I cannot understand K&N's statement "There could be upside to our profit forecasts as our investment assumptions of 2.5% Fixed Deposit yields are fairly prudent to account for its RM900m near cash holding." since I cannot find where the 900 million...

Let's look at the extremely 'cheap' reasoning from K&N again.

  • Extremely cheap valuations. P&O is trading at 3x FY11 PER and 0.55x P/BV

Now... let me say again... of course I believe that a company should be valued based on what it can earn in the future. Yes... future earnings are very important...

But... but.... this is where it gets tricky.. and this is where the investing public can be fed with the incredible sky high earnings estimates... which inadvertently does make a stock appear extremely cheap. :P

Here's K&N estimates...

You need to click on the image to see a clearer and bigger view. :D

Anyway.. from the table... KN said P&O is projected to earn some 32.87 million for this current fiscal year 2010.

Well.. remember the Star Business article earlier? K&N acknowledged that for the first half of the current fiscal year, P&O have a current net lost of 1.4 million.

Now let's look at P&O announcements on Bursa website.

  1. May 2010: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/3/2010 - P&O made 3.247 million for the quarter. - Current half year losses were 1.417 million. (as stated by K&N)
  2. Feb 2010: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/12/2009 - P&O stated it lost 21.352 million for the quarter!

Now this is where I am so lost ( Yeah.. what to do since I am not an accounting expert. :P ) and confused. Q1 in Feb 2010, P&O said it lost some 21.352 million. Q2 it said it made some 3.247 million. But.. it's half year total losses was only 1.417 million.

Me? I am so lost. :P

Anway... here's a couple more quarterly earnings from P&O.

  1. Nov 2009: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 30/9/2009
  2. Aug 2009: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 30/6/2009

Now using the current 2010 half year net loss of reference, K&N had estimated P&O earnings for fy 2010 to be 32.87 million.

Now I know, earnings projections and estimates, are incredibly difficult. More so for me, since I am not a Sotong. :P

But... an earnings estimates of 32.87 million when the company is sitting on half year losses of 1.4 million???

Surely that's a bit too optimistic, yes?

yeah... from K&N earnings estimate table.. we see K&N using a PAT (profit after tax) growth estimate of 120%!!!

a 120% growth estimate!

huhu!

Rather incredible eh? Considering the fact P&O made 14.9 million and current half year it is losing 1.4 million. But yet, K&N states it can achieve an earnings growth of 120%!!!

huhu!

But... KN did NOT say P&O is cheap based on 2010 figures!

Instead K&N states P&O is cheap based on 2011 figures!

And what is K&N earning estimates for P&O again? 43.47 million!!!!

huhu!

Wiki Wiki!

And as stated in the earnings estimate table... this is an PAT growth estimate of 32%!

How?

Yeah babe. K&N is saying P&O is cheap based on this 2011 earnings. Only trading at 3x PE multiple based on 2011 earnings!!!

I just love how they do it.

:D

K&N report continues...


  • 92% upside to base case valuation of RM 1.15. This values the group at an undemanding FY11 PER of 6x, which is at the low end of the 6-15x 2010/11 PER of Malaysian general insurers.
  • M&As valuation of RM 1.65 (translating to 4.2x). Although there is already substantial price upside to our base case valuation, the stock is worth even more on M&As basis. Our M&As values P&O’s in range of 1.5-2.0x FY11 P/B V, which is in comparison with first phase consolidation of Malaysian banking sector.

waa.... two type of valuations. Base case valuation of rm 1.15 and M&A valuation of rm 1.65!

Terror la!

:P

Then I reminded myself that K&N report is a 15 page report! oO

Do I want to go thru it all?

Nah....

so how?

Would P&O continue its fly up, up and away?

Seriously? I do not know.

----------------

ADDUM:

regarding the 900 million near cash holding... on page 10 of the report.

  • Investment Gain. However, in view of the group’s potential earnings volatility, we have factored in some prudent investment yield assumptions in our forecasts.

    For example, the yield for the group’s investment portfolio could be higher than we have assumed of 2.4% which attached to only 6-months Fixed Deposit rates. Its RM900m near cash/ all cash position, may generate bigger profits if increase equity exposure in any market dips rather than the small profit that we are projecting. In addition, our projected rise 2.4% yield to its RM900m cash for FY11 could prove conservative, as it is slightly lower than market expectation.

Hmm... let me look at May's earnings again: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/3/2010





How?

Oh.. ps: P&O does do some money lending business too. :P

  • Pursuant to paragraph 8.23(2)(e) of the Main Market Listing Requirements of Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad, the Company wishes to announce the moneylending activities (as part of the ordinary course of business) of its wholly-owned subsidiary, P & O Capital Sdn Bhd for the second quarter ended 31 March 2010, as set out in the attachment.

    POB~POC (2Q 2010).doc

Read more...

Beat The Estimates Game: K&N Buy Recommendation On HPI Resources

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Do you follow the reports on Bursa's CBRS?

Link to Bursa's CBRS Research reports

I was reading through the report from K&N Kenanga on HPI Resources and since I am blogging on it, (LOL! ), I guess you can guess this posting probably isn't anything good.

:P

On 7th August 2009: K&N had a report oneBursa: Above expectations (clickable line to CBRS pdf file) K&N had a BUY recommendation.

  • BUY RM1.30 Target Price: RM1.86
    Forecast upgraded with FY10 profit projection increased by 29.7% as we factor in a higher margins taking into account the better than expected 4Q09 numbers. We also take the opportunity to introduce our FY11 projection. Recommendation is also upgraded to a BUY from a HOLD with new target price of RM1.86 based on a 30% discount to its NTA of RM2.65.

Here's HPI earnings report then: Quarterly rpt on consolidated results for the financial period ended 31/5/2009

As you can see, based on a y-y comparison, HPI earnings jumped from 11 million to 18.8 million.

And K&N earnings 'estimates' for fy 2010 was 18.9 (no growth? :P) and fy 2011 was 19.1 million. (see page 2 of the pdf file: K&N had a report oneBursa: Above expectations )

On 28th Nov 2009, HPI reported its earnings. Here's the simple compiled table.

On 3rd Novemeber 2009: K&N's resarch report for HPI was 'Above Expectations' (CBRS pdf file link) HPI had a bonus issue then and K&N recommendation was still a BUY.

  • RM1.61 (cum bonus) RM1.29 (ex- bonus) Target Price: RM1.77 (ex- bonus)
    Forecast upgrade as we model in higher margins taking into account the better economic conditions ahead. While we maintain our revenue projections for FY2010 and FY2011, our net profit projection for FY10 is raised by 22.2% to RM23.1m and FY11 by 24.3% to RM23.8m. BUY maintained with a higher target price of RM 1.77 (ex-bonus issue) or RM2.21 on a cum basis based on 4x CY2010F. The low multiple is due to the stock’s small cap status and potential cyclical earnings.

Ok, HPI's Q1 earnings was 6.341 million and on an annualised basis, HPI's earnings could easily reach 25 million. So KN's upgrade in net profit projection was expected.

20th Jan 2010, HPI reported its Q2 earnings.


Ytd net profit already 12.467 million. Nearly half of K&N's net profit projection of 23.1 million.

K&N gave it a BUY recommendation and called it 'In Line with expectations. (CBRS pdf file link. )

  • BUY RM1.47 Target Price: RM2.21
    Forecast is maintained but target price raised to RM2.21 from RM1.77 previously, ascribing a 5x CY2010F as opposed to 4x earlier. The recent multiple expansion experienced by our driven by an improving economic outlook prompts us to use a higher multiple to value the stock. BUY maintained.

Earnings forecast for fy 2010 remained at 23.1 million.

5th April 2010, HPI reported its Q3 earnings.


Ooops... now that was a 'poor' looking quarter, yes? Now on an annualised basis, it would appear that HPI would fall a bit short of estimates, eh?

So what did K&N do and say?

K&N called it 'Disappointing' but gave HPI a HOLD recommendation. (CBRS pdf file link)

  • HOLD RM1.65 Target Price: RM1.60
    Forecast trimmed given heightening risk to profitability. While maintaining our topline forecast, margins are lowered as we factor in a tougher environment going forth. Re-pricing of its end products could lag the commodity and currency cycles in the near term. Lowering our net forecast by 22% to RM18m for FY10 and another 32% for FY11 to RM16.2m. Target price lowered to RM1.60 based on revised 5x CY10F. Recommendation also downgraded to HOLD from BUY.

oO

Net earnings lowered back down to 18 million and most interestingly, K&N lowered the fy 2011 earnings forecast to just 16.2 million.

A couple days ago, HPI announced its earnings.


Net earnings came in at 7.244 million. That was decent, yes?

Anyway, this meant that HPI easnings for fy 2010 was 22.843 million.

But K&N had already lowered its earnings forecast to just 18 million. LOL!

And on today's report on eBursa, K&N gave HPI back a BUY call rating! (CBRS pdf file link)

( ps: HPI shares HAD ALREADY rallied ( rocketed to the orbit is a better word :P ) to some 1.84! You need to check out the chart at the bottom of the posting :P)

The first paragraph... :P

  • FY10 results were above our expectations. While 12M10 revenue of RM372.6m was in line, net profit of RM22.8m was trending 27% higher due to a strong uptick in the last quarter on the back of stronger margins. Gross margins improved by 42 basis points to 17.8% in 4Q10 from a disappointing 3Q10 after an effective cost pass-through underpinned by higher paper prices in general.

LOL! Of course it was above their expectations since the expected net earnings was revised and reduced so much lower! From 23.1 million, the earnings estimates was just lowered to 16.2 million.

Yeah... as they say... HPI beat the earnings estimates.. results were above expectations!

LOL!

  • BUY RM1.84 Target Price: RM2.89
    Forecast upgrade with FY11F net profit raised by 58% mainly on the back of higher margins as sumed. We also introduce our FY12F with revenue of RM447m and net profit of RM28.8m. More engaging management with the investment community, improved transparency couple with the undemanding valuations should be positive re -rating catalysts. Dividend of 5sen (tax exempt) declared which is a pleasant surprise, yielding 2.7%. Risks remained with the volatile paper prices which accounts for 70% of its cost of production which could impact profitability depending on timing and effectiveness of any cost pass through. Upgrading call to BUY with a new target price o RM2.89 on 6x FY11F.

And K&N raised the fy 2011 estimates by 58%!!!!!

LOL!

So fy 2011 estimates... from a net earnings of just 16.2 million, K&N has now raised it to 25.7 million!

No wonder the buy recommendation now comes with a very chunky target price of rm 2.89!

And apparently this is how 'the beat the earnings estimates' is being played..... worldwide. :P




ps. I dunno if this share can or not. LOL!

ps. And I dunno if K&N owns any Sotong. :P

Read more...

Bina Puri: Target Price 1.77

Sunday, July 18, 2010

I was forwarded a copy of Bina Puri's report from Kenanga Research. It states BOLDLY Target Price 1.77!

I presume that the sender was mocking my posting this morning
A Quick Simple Look At Bina Puri's Valuation

Fine. :D

Here's KN's report on Bina Puri. (ps: Kenanga uses 6% margin. Mine? 3%. Like I said, pick your own poison. :D )




Read more...

Update on Sino Hua An Losses

Monday, May 17, 2010

Update on Sino Hua-An Lost Money.... Again

So Sino Hua-An lost money... again. I know it's just only 2.48 million. Yes only rm 2.48 million.

What's the big deal? Nothing really. :D

Anyway, as mentioned in the posting
Sino Hua-An Lost Money.... Again, KN Research said the following back on 1st March 2010.

  • Outlook. We remain positive of the China’s economy robustness.According to the Worldsteel, China will continue as the biggest driver of world steel demand, however, the domestic steel industry is expected to grow at moderation and at 5% growth . Nevertheless, we are lowering our FY10 net estimate by 9% to RM64.7m as we revised marginally lower of our assumption of coke price. We are also introducing our FY11 earnings estimates with net profit of RM70.6m. The pricing sluggishness of coke and short-term steel demand volatility remain as key risks to our earnings forecasts.

    Maintain BUY with lower target price at RM0.58 based on FY10 PER of 10x (in line with the small-to -medium size Malaysian steel players and 30% discount to its China’s peers).
Here's the screen shot.



Now with Sino Hua An losing 2.48 million and KN's estimates at 64.7 million, I wonder what KN will say in their report.

Sino Hua An back then, on 1st March 2010, was 48.5 sen. KN gave it a buy with a Target Price of 58 sen.

Sino Hua An is now 40 sen.

Will KN lower their ratings and target prices?

The answer? Yes they did.

The rating is now a HOLD with a target price of 37 sen.

  • FY10 net forecast trimmed lower by 29.4% to 42m. We maintain our expectations of Hua-An turning a profit in FY10. Despite lowering our FY10 net profit by 29.4% to 42m given a weak 1Q10, we are expecting a profit turnout in 2Q10 boosted by swift recovery in steel demand and favourable pricing of metallurgical coke at above RMB1,976 per tonne. Additionally, we are maintaining our net profit in FY11 at RM70.6m based on assumed annualised average price of RMB1,900 per tonne of coke and RMB1,240 per tonne of coal in our forecast. The unfavourable pricing of coal and short-term steel demand volatility however, remain as key risks to our earnings forecasts.

    Downgrade to HOLD with lower target price at RM0.37 (previously RM0.58) based on FY10 PER of 10x (in line with the small-to-medium size Malaysian steel players and 30% discount to its China’s peers).


Hmm... they lowered the net profit forecast by 29.4% to 42 million.

Hmmm... I dunno... do you think the net profit is still rather high?

Do you think this company is really, really under performing?

----------------

As mentioned in the early posting, OSK's previous earnings forecast for Sino Hua An was much, much higher than KN, at rm 100.3 million. I am disappointed because I have yet to see OSK make an update on Sino Hua An's earnings today. I wonder... why... hmmm....

Read more...

Featured Report: KN on Swee Joo

Monday, August 24, 2009

This morning I made short notes on Swee Joo's extremely poor earnings results. I just got a copy of KN notes on Swee Joo.

Their recommendation on Swee Joo is 'witheld'!

  • Cutting FY09 and FY10 forecasts by 342.9% and 56.8% on weaker than expected tankers performance . Rates recovery for tankers we believe are less likely in the near term given excess vessels supply. Turnaround will now hinge on management’s restructuring efforts for its vessels and borrowings portfolio. Our call and TP are withheld in the exercise of Kenanga 's duties under the applicable laws, rules, regulations, policies and procedures for the time being in force, and is not a reflection of expected returns .




oO

Errr... like this also can???

Read more...

Featured Report: Kenanga On Sino Hua-An

Monday, August 17, 2009

Posted last night: Update On Sino Hua-An

I chuckled when I see the market liking the 'losing-less-money' factor.

Who cares it is losing money? Most important it is losing less money! - lol.. does this even sound logical?

Yeah but then this is the stock markets and in the stock markets, the spin masters can make anything bad sound good. Am I right or perhaps am I flawed?

I do not know.

However, my mind is telling me to use another perspective.

Imagine this...

Picture this little girl telling her mum.

Little Girl: "Mummy, I failed my Maths but on the bright side, I got less wrong answers!"

Now do you think the Mummy should reward the little girl for getting less mistakes or should a fail be a fail?

I do not know about you but what I do know is that a fail is a fail. Which means a bloody red mark is stained on the report book!

So should one jump up for joy that a company is losing less money?

I wrote on Hua-An exactly a year ago, last August,
Regarding Sino Hua-An. In that posting I was bemused and puzzled by the following issue.



  • The earnings are decent no? But there is NO Growth and now earnings margins is under massive pressure.

    And would this be one reason why potential 'investors' or buyers would be worried about?

    And what about the company's product? IMHO this is also a huge concern because the past couple of months, metallurgical coke and its by-products have had one MASSIVE bull run. Prices had been extremely favourable and logical reasoning would suggest that this favourable coke prices would have boosted Huann's bottom line. But as we can see above earnings table, this coke bull run did not translate to better earnings for Huann. Would this be a concern since we have here a company whose key product is having one hell of a bull run but yet the company produces flat earnings. What does this say about the Quality of the company and the Business? Not very good yes? Do you reckon such reasoning is flawed?

It was a bull run for the metallurgical coke and its by products.

However the bull run never resulted into huge fortune for Hua-An.

And the local pros are suggesting to buy based on a recovery story? You know this makes me wonder because when times were so good last year, Hua-An earnings slumped. Now they want us to buy Sino Hua-An???

Sure boh? How Hua-An is at 0.545 sen. Who wants?

And then it so ironic.

Back exactly a year ago, I had a copy of KN Kenanga report on Sino Hua An. Price of Hua-An was also at 0.545!

Dejavu. :P

Now on the previous day back in August 2008, Hua-An reported earnings of 36.916 million and half year earnings was at 72.484 million!

And this is what Kenanga wrote in their report.


Despite calling it a BELOW expectations, Kenanga still gave it a BUY rating and a target price of 0.88 sen.

Remember Hua-An year-to-date earnings were 72.484 million.

Last night Hua-An's lost some 13.279 million and year-to-date losses were 36.911 million.

And Hua-An stock price is also 0.545. :p2

Despite losing money, Kenanga insist that the prospect is bright! (losing less money is good eh?)



Viola!

Kenanga still have a buy on Sino Hua-An but with a lower target price.

Yeah.. losing less money is good. :D

So who wants Hua-An?

Read more...

Will Bintulu Port pay out rm400m??

Sunday, April 6, 2008

Published on Business Times: Bintulu Port can pay out RM400m: Kenanga

  • BINTULU Port Holdings Bhd has the potential to pay shareholders up to RM1 a share or RM400 million in total, due to its strong balance sheet, a research house said.

    The company, which operates the world's largest liquefied natural gas (LNG) export terminal, has cash of some RM470 million as at December 31 2007. It has zero borrowings.

    "Strong balance sheet also provides room for capital management," Kenanga Investment Bank Bhd said in an initiation report dated March 31.

I am simply NOT happy with such insinuation at all.

Yes, this stock might have the cash but there is NO written guarantee that it will share its excess cash.

Ok, talk is too cheap. How about an example of a cash rich company NOT sharing its excess cash? Well try look at UAC.

Think about that!

Read more...

KN's commentary on K-Euro

Wednesday, January 3, 2007

I found the following research write-up quite strange. (my comments in green italics)

======>>>>>

K&N Kenanga 3Q FY07 Result Update Date: 3 January 2007

Kumpulan Europlus Berhad

Price: RM0.420 Recommendation: HOLD

Analyst: Teoh Cheng Guan

Kumpulan Europlus Berhad ("KEURO") reported an improved set of 3QFY07 operating results. On an annualized basis, 9mFY07 revenue was 66.9% below our FY07 estimate, and 9mFY07 loss before tax and net loss were 207.5% and 263.1% larger than our FY07 estimates, respectively, mainly due to RM115.8m-additional losses at Talam, which was booked in 2QFY07, in respect of the latter’s FY06 audited results.

===>>> Improved results? LOL!!! How could it be improved set of results when the set of results is way below their estimates? 66.9% below their estimate!!! And best of all... we are talking about revenue (sales) estimates here. Wonder what happened to profit estimates? Does earnings not matter? :s4:

3QFY07 turnover declined 48.2% y-y to RM10.3m due to winding down of its construction business as a substantial portion of its on-going projects had either been completed or were near completion. 3QFY07 profit before tax and net profit turned around from losses of RM69.9m and RM69.5m in 3QFY06 to slight profit of RM0.5m (+100.7% y-y) and RM0.5m (+100.8% y-y), respectively; due mainly to: (1) a turnaround in its own operating performance; and (2) 88.5% -reduction in losses attributable to Talam.

==>>>> *cough*... losses... :s25:

In terms of q-q comparison, 2QFY07 revenue improved 59.1% q-q due to sand mining activities by the construction division. The 2QFY07 loss before tax and net loss of RM115.8m and RM115.3m improved 100.4% and 100.5% q-q to a small PBT and net profit of RM0.5m and RM0.5m, respectively, in 3QFY07 mainly because 2QFY07 results were hit by the earlier mentioned RM115.8m-losses attributable to Talam.

9mFY07 or YTD turnover recorded a 49.5% y-y decline to RM26.7m as a substantial proportion of its on-going construction projects have either been completed or near completion. 9mFY07 loss before tax and net loss decreased by 15.3% y-y and 15.4% y-y to RM113.7m and RM114.1m, respectively, due mainly to a strong turnaround in its own operating performance despite higher losses attributable to Talam.

2. Recommendation

We are cutting our FY07 revenue estimate by 66.3% to RM36.3m to reflect the depletion of the on-going construction projects and non-consolidation of revenue in relation to the Canal City ("CC") projects.

==>>>Cutting the revenue estimates again? LOL!!!

We are also increasing our FY07 loss before tax and net loss estimates by 133.1% and 175.9% to RM114.9m and RM115.67m, respectively, to incorporate the RM115.8m-additional losses at Talam, which was booked in 2QFY07, in respect of the latter’s FY06 audited results.

==>>> Eh? Increasing fy07 losses before taxes and net losses by 133.1% and 175.9%!!!!

:s50:

Going forward, KEURO’s profitability will be highly dependent on:

(1) The successful execution of the Flood Mitigation ("FM") project, which is part of the RM6.5b -CC projects that involve the construction of an 18-km FM canal, a 42km toll-free road (Shah Alam – Shah Alam 2 Expressway) and a new upmarket mixed development township to be developed over a 7 to 8-year period; and

(2) The successful award and execution of the West Coast Expressway ("WCE") project, which is key to the entry of IJM Corporation ("IJM") as a 30%-strategic shareholder in KEURO.

Our newly introduced FY08 forecasts suggest an earnings turnaround despite exclusion of the potential contribution from the WCE-related construction works.

Excluding the RM115.8m-loss at Talam in respect of its audited FY06 results, KEURO’s 9mFY07 results do not look too bad. The Talam-problem is very much discounted in our judgment. Management is also turning cautiously optimistic on the group’s prospect due to improving construction sector outlook and seems confident that the CC-project will take off in FY08.

Downside risk could be rather limited, as the market seems to believe that the award of the WCE-concession,

==>>> LOL!!! But aren't you all expecting more losses? If so, how could the downside risk be rather limited????? :s39:

and therefore the entry of IJM as a strategic shareholder, is a matter of when and not if.

===>>> yeah... everything hinges on IJM to BAILOUT Keuro, isn't it? :s37:

We are maintaining our HOLD -rating on KEURO with a revised target price of RM0.35 (+34.6% from RM0.26 previously) based on an increased P/NTA of 1.5x given an expected earnings turnaround in FY08.

===>> Hmmo.. let me get this straight up..

more losses, below estimates = +34.6% in target price???

:s31:

Oh, silly billy me, IJM wants to buy (bailout) Keuro! LOL! :s39:

NTA/share stood at RM0.233 as at 31 October 2006.

:s50: :s50: :s50: :s50: :s50:

Their target price of rm0.35 is more than Keuro NTA woh!!!!!!!

Like this also can???

:s48: :s48:

Read more...

  © Blogger templates Newspaper by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP